New Threads Only:  Add to Google Reader or Homepage
New Threads & Replies:  Add to Google Reader or Homepage
Forums are for serious investors only. GuruFocus Forum Rules.

Forum List » Guru News and Commentaries
Guru News, Stock picks and commentaries
New Topic
Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Forum ListMessage ListNew TopicLog In
Analyst Ratings and Best Buy Stock
Posted by: The Science of Hitting (IP Logged)
Date: March 26, 2013 10:28AM

Figuring out exactly what service Wall Street analysts provide for investors (meaning people who think like business owners) has become increasingly unclear to me. Financial theory suggests that a company’s intrinsic value is equal to the present value of expected future net cash flows to the owners of the business, discounted at the appropriate rate; yet in their attempt to serve two masters, most analyst reports explicitly state that the research presented is offering opinions (buy, sell, hold) with the intention of outperforming in the coming 12 months – a goal that leads to a critical question: Are analysts looking for undervalued stocks or catalysts? In the case of a company that’s undervalued, but likely to face short-term issues, what is our equity analyst to do?

The volatility surrounding Best Buy (BBY)'s stock price in the past few months shows just how quickly fundamental analysis becomes a game of follow the leader/stock price. A year ago, BBY common traded in the low to mid $20’s per share; for months on end, culminating at the end of 2012, the stock continued its decline – all the way to a low of around $11 per share. For the analyst needing to make a 12-month recommendation, the recent activity suggested that there was little love for Best Buy – and no reason to suspect that would change. As such, the analysts herded together to present such a view (data presented is from Marketwatch.com):

BBY Analyst Ratings Three Months Ago
Buy 1
Hold 21
Sell 1


Fast forward 90 days, and the market has suddenly become enamored with Best Buy – with analysts being the giddiest of all. With the stock up more than 100% from its lows – lows reached roughly 90 days ago – here’s the current recommendations from the same community (most of the upgrades have come in the past few weeks):

BBY Analyst Ratings Today
Buy 9
Hold 16
Sell 1


This is off a relatively small sample size, but the change is quite clear – from a single analyst recommending Best Buy common stock at half the current valuation a short three months ago, more than one-third of all analysts covering the company now consider BBY a buy.

The analyst group presented has pointed to a couple things in justifying these upgrades, namely a change in management, a 0.9% jump in comparable sales in the fourth quarter, and the company’s willingness to fight back on prices against Amazon (of course this doesn’t address the bigger concern of cost structure – the sole reason why so many are calling for the death of brick-and-mortar, or the fact that many of the company’s product categories continue to show the strongest shift to ecommerce; these questions will likely be saved for when the stock starts to sputter).

This brings up an important question: If analyst estimates are based solely on cosmetic changes or short-term improvements or declines in business trends – with little to no concern about how those changes relate to valuation or the attractiveness of the common stock – then what good are analyst recommendations? How can you be so concerned with near-term price movements – as mandated by their 12-month forecast horizon – yet still focus on intrinsic value?

I guess it will take somebody smarter than myself to circle this square…


Stocks Discussed: BBY,
Rate this post:

Rating: 4.3/5 (23 votes)



Re Analyst Ratings and Best Buy Stock
Posted by: Cornelius Chan (IP Logged)
Date: March 26, 2013 10:13PM

"You know Wall Street," Warren tried to reassure me. "People don't think in a long-term way there."
— Personal History, Katharine Graham


Stocks Discussed: BBY,
Rate this post:

Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes)



Re Analyst Ratings and Best Buy Stock
Posted by: The Science of Hitting (IP Logged)
Date: March 27, 2013 06:54AM

CWR,

Great quote - thanks!



Stocks Discussed: BBY,
Rate this post:

Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes)



Re Analyst Ratings and Best Buy Stock
Posted by: luishernadez (IP Logged)
Date: April 10, 2013 09:33AM

Science,

Great article, thanks for posting.

Regarding WS analysts, that´s why I NEVER look at analysts recommendations and/or reports. They are completely useless. They are definitely playing a different game than all of us (value guys). Their game is the fluctuation of the price for the next 1-3 months. That´s it.


Stocks Discussed: BBY,
Rate this post:

Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes)



Re Analyst Ratings and Best Buy Stock
Posted by: The Science of Hitting (IP Logged)
Date: April 10, 2013 07:26PM

Luishernadez,

Agreed! Thanks for the comment!


Stocks Discussed: BBY,
Rate this post:

Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes)





Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Please Login if you have an account or Create a Free Account if you don't
Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names | Earn affiliate commissions by embedding GuruFocus Charts
GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to $400 per referral. ( Learn More)
Free 7-day Trial
FEEDBACK