|New Threads Only:|
|New Threads & Replies:|
Forum List » Value Ideas and Strategies|
Share and discuss value investing ideas and investing strategies.
Whole Foods as a Short
Posted by: mdhargrave (IP Logged)
Date: March 4, 2013 09:53AM
The highly popular organic foods company, Whole Foods (WFM), tumbled nearly 10% after posting quarterly results earlier this month. A slowdown in its business, coupled with rising costs, spurred speculation that the high-end grocery market might be worth shorting. So what are investors to do? Go long, do nothing or go short?
Whole Foods' last quarterly EPS came in at $0.78, up 20% from the same quarter last year. The frightening part for investors was management's poor guidance for 2013. Whole Foods now expects to see full-year 2013 EPS of $2.83 to $2.87, compared to previous analysts' expectations of $2.90. The lowered guidance comes as a result of margin compression, which the company expects to see for the rest of the year.
Part of this compression is related to aggressive store openings. Whole Foods opened 25 stores in 2012, with plans to accelerate the pace of openings over the next few years, including opening 32 in 2013. Notable other expansion opportunities include the possibility of entering Canada and the UK. So, for now, it appears this expected rise in costs will be for future growth.
Other major grocers include Kroger (KR), Safeway (SWY), SuperValu (SVU) and fellow organic grocer Fresh Market (TFM).
Kroger has managed to defend its market share from small competitors that have entered the market over the years. This is due in part to consumers that have traded down to cheaper brands from the higher priced organic foods. However, investors are not overly excited by Kroger, in part due to changing consumer preferences, but also given the grocer's high debt-to-capital ratio. The debt-to-capital ratio for the end of the third quarter was 70%.
Safeway has also seen serious pressure from larger operators like Kroger, not to mention from new entrants into the market. The grocer saw EPS decline by an average of 4.5% over the last five years.
SuperValu, yet another struggling grocer, has caught a break. The grocer has seen stock price strength of late thanks to the proposed sale of part of its retail segment stores, which should help the company refocus on sales growth at its key chain, Save-A-Lot, while stabilizing its distribution business.
Operating margins for SuperValu’s retail segment (the part it hopes to shed) are only 0.6%, but Save-A-Lot is at 3.2%, and the independent business segment at 2.6%. The new Supervalu will have a greater weighting toward higher-margin businesses.
The Fresh Market operates in the southeast, mid-west, and mid-atlantic U.S. Wall Street expects this particular organic foods company to grow EPS at nearly 23% annually for the next five years, versus the 18.5% for Whole Foods. As far as how valuation stacks up, both of the organic foods companies trades at the very high end of the industry, on both a P/E and P/CF basis:
5-Yr. Expected EPS Growth
I wouldn’t be jumping in on the long side of Whole Foods, either, but The Fresh Market may well be a solid stock to buy. If we take a look at the two, The Fresh Market outperforms with respect to generating returns for investors, with a return on investment that is nearly double that of Whole Foods:
Return on Investment
The Global Powers of Retailing report published by Deloitte Touche and STORES shows that Kroger is the 5th largest U.S. retailer, Whole Foods the 9th, Safeway the 24th, SuperValu 31st, Whole Foods 104th, with The Fresh Market not making the list. That's part of the reason I like it: It's an underrated and under-the-radar grocer with room to grow.
As a believer in of the health food epidemic and the rise of health-concise consumers, it might well be worth betting on one of the top organic foods companies. While I can’t gather enough conviction to call Whole Foods a short, I would call Whole Foods a hold and The Fresh Market as a buy.
Stocks Discussed: WFM, SWY, SVU, KR, TFM,