|New Threads Only:|
|New Threads & Replies:|
Forum List » Income Investors' Forum|
Ideas for Income Investors. High Dividend Stocks, Mutual Funds etc.
CSX Corporation Appears Cheap at Under $20
Posted by: Dividend Monk (IP Logged)
Date: December 5, 2012 08:28AM
CSX Corporation operates a large railroad system that serves most of the eastern United States.
-Seven Year Revenue Growth Rate: 4.6%
-Seven Year EPS Growth Rate: 11.4%
-Seven Year Dividend Growth Rate: 33.1%
-Current Dividend Yield: 2.85%
-Balance Sheet Strength: Leveraged, Fair
OverviewCSX Corporation (NYSE: CSX) is a large railroad company with over 21,000 miles of track in 23 states. The company had a period of poor management and performance, but in the last several years has rebounded to become a strong performer as a Class I railroad. According to the company’s Baird’s Industrial conference presentation, the revenue breakdown for CSX so far in 2012 was as follows:
General merchandise is the largest segment, accounting for 41% of total revenue. This is further divided into Automotive, Metals, Chemicals, Phosphates, Agriculture, Food and Consumer, Forest, and Exports.
Coal is a large individual component of revenue, with 14% of total revenue coming from domestic coal transport, and 7% of total revenue coming from export coal transport, for a total of 21%. Domestic coal is facing strong headwinds currently.
For CSX, 38% of revenue came from intermodal shipping.
RatiosPrice to Earnings: 11
Price to Free Cash Flow: 40
Price to Book: 2.3
Return on Equity: 22%
(Chart Source: DividendMonk.com)
For both of these charts, the 2012 figures actually refer to the trailing twelve months, which include the last 3 months of 2011 and the first 9 months of 2012.
Revenue over this period grew at an average rate of 4.6% per year, but the growth was erratic due to the large hit the company took during the recession.
Earnings and Dividends
(Chart Source: DividendMonk.com)
Earnings growth over this period was substantial, at 11.4% per year. A significant portion of this was due to stock buybacks.
The dividend currently yields 2.85% with a low earnings payout ratio. Free cash flow is very low in the trailing twelve month period and barely covers the dividend, but this is due to a combination of capital expenditures above their long-term baseline, and a recent moderate reduction in operating cash flow due to reductions in coal transport volume. So overall, their dividend appears quite safe going forward.
The dividend has grown at a 30+% annualized rate over the last several years, but this was partially due to an expanding payout ratio. The company targets a 30-35% payout ratio, which is where it’s currently at, so the future dividend growth should be roughly in line with EPS growth.
Approximate historical dividend yield at beginning of each year:
How Does CSX Spend Its Cash?
The company lists its three priorities, in order, as:
Capital Investment- CSX expects to invest 16-17% of revenue into core capital investment.
Dividends- CSX expects to pay out 30-35% of TTM earnings as dividends.
Share Repurchases- The company is finishing up a $2 billion share repurchase program with plans for a new one.
During the fiscal years 2009, 2010, and 2011, the company brought in over $3.2 in free cash flow. Over this same period, $1.2 billion was paid out as dividends and $3 billion was spent to buy back shares and reduce the share count. The number of shares peaked at nearly 1.4 billion shares in 2006, but has since decreased to around 1.05 billion, because the company spent over $7 billion buying back stock. As a reference, the market cap is currently around $20 billion. No cash was spent on acquisitions.
Balance SheetThe total debt/equity ratio of CSX is slightly over 100%. Total debt/income is a bit under 5x. The debt has been increasing over the last several years from approximately $5 billion to $9 billion. There is negligible goodwill.
The interest coverage ratio is a bit over 6x, which is on the low side, but stable. Overall, the balance sheet has some leverage, but remains stable, and is in fair condition.
Investment ThesisThis is a sister article to the recent report on Norfolk Southern. Both of these companies operate railroads with nearly identical geographic locations, have nearly identical market capitalizations and stock valuations, have similar balance sheets, have similar priorities of capital investment, dividends, and buybacks, and they both recently took a cash flow and stock price hit from a reduction in coal volume (which is due to their nearly identical geographic footprint).
From an investor’s perspective, these are very similar equities, so it’s worth highlighting some subtle differences:
-Higher dividend yield of 3.32%
-Slightly stronger balance sheet
-Slightly smaller rail network, with less extension north and south across the eastern coast
-Consistently strong operating performance
-Has slightly more exposure to coal, which is a major headwind currently
-Lower dividend yield of 2.85%
-Slightly weaker balance sheet
-Slightly larger rail network, with more extension north and south across the eastern coast
-Had poor financial management years ago, but has rebounded with strong performance
-Has slightly less exposure to coal, which is a major headwind currently
Between the two, I consider Norfolk to be a slightly more resilient dividend stock, while CSX is possibly a bit more of a value play. In general, the market appears to be treating these two businesses very efficiently with the same stock valuation.
RisksThe volume and revenue of a railroad company is highly dependent on the economy. Weak macroeconomic conditions mean less freight is shipped. Since railroads have substantial fixed operating costs, a decrease in volume and revenue results in an amplified decrease in earnings and free cash flow.
CSX and competitor Norfolk Southern have very similar overlapping rail networks over the eastern half of the United States. This will keep pricing rather competitive and efficient.
The company recently took a hit from decreases in coal volume. Coal is being used less in the region for electricity generation, so their domestic coal shipments have a strong headwind that likely isn’t going away soon due to the efficiency of natural gas. The rest of the segments of CSX will have to carry the coal segment and the overall company forward.
Conclusion and ValuationThe company is capable of moving 1 ton of freight 500 miles on one gallon of fuel, which is three times more efficient than trucking. Railroad companies have competitors, but due to the literally entrenched position of their assets, rail companies have some economic advantages as long as the capital is managed well and as long as economic conditions remain viable.
Unless free cash flow picks up substantially, the share buybacks will have to slow down, because the company has been leveraging their balance sheet in a low interest rate environment to reduce the share count and accelerate EPS and dividend growth.
If the operating cash flow rebounds a bit from the recent drop, up to $3.3-$3.4 billion or so, and if the company invests 16-17% of revenue into capital projects as planned, then that leaves around $1.3-$1.4 billion for dividends and buybacks, which is around 7% of the current market cap. As the shareholder yield, that’s roughly the return that an investor would receive with no growth. If 3-4% revenue growth is estimated, based largely on inflation and mild volume increases, then the company is in a position to provide a good rate of return.
Using the Dividend Discount Model with a 10% discount rate as a target rate of return, the company is currently fairly valued at a price of just under $20 based on the estimate of 7% long-term annualized dividend growth (4% from buybacks, 3% from top line growth). If the dividend growth rate is estimated to be 8% instead, then the fair value jumps to nearly $30 for the same discount rate.
I believe that the current stock price of CSX of just under $20 is fairly valued or moderately undervalued, just like Norfolk Southern. In addition, if investors are bullish about the fundamentals of the company over the long-term, but want to enter the stock with a lower cost basis to increase the margin of safety, then selling January 2014 puts at a strike price of $20 can result in a 13-14% annualized rate of return if the option is not exercised, or entering the stock with a cost basis of under $17.50 if the option is exercised.
Full Disclosure: As of this writing, I have no position in CSX or NSC, but NSC is currently on my watch list.
Stocks Discussed: CSX, NSC,