BE WARY OF MAGIC FORMULA STOCKS THAT GROW THROUGH ACQUISITIONS
A much more detailed example of goodwill accounting can be found here.
So how does this relate to Magic Formula Investing (MFI)? As one of the core adjustments made in calculating a comparable return on capital, Joel Greenblatt subtracts goodwill from total assets. Ostensibly, this is to remove accounting differences that occur from company to company and compare firms based solely on their returns on tangible assets.
However, removing goodwill when calculating return on capital fails to penalize companies that routinely overpay for acquisitions in order to grow. In effect, MFI can reward "empire building", where firms will pay any price to keep the revenue and profits lines going upwards at rates that satisfy Wall Street. However, overpaying for acquisitions does not create value. It simply removes capital that could have been returned in the form of dividends or share buybacks.
To illustrate how ignoring goodwill can skew the Magic Formula's view of a company, take the case of current MFI stock Viacom (VIA-B). The firm lists over $11 billion dollars of goodwill, about 50% of total assets. Most of this has built up in a complex web of acquisitions over decades. For example, many of Viacom's cable channels (like CMT and VH1) were obtained via acquisition.
Removing goodwill from a MFI pre-tax return on capital equation has a drastic effect on results, as seen below:
Return on Capital (minus goodwill) = EBIT / (Invested Capital - Goodwill) = 3,277 / (17,628 - 11,035) = 53.5%
Return on Capital (with goodwill) = 3,277 / 17,628 = 18.6%
Not accounting for Viacom's history as a highly acquisitive firm makes the company look a lot more efficient than it actually has been.
Now let's look at the opposite side of the equation: a Magic Formula stock with no goodwill, which has generated high returns on capital strictly through organic growth. One such stock is Aeropostale (ARO):
Return on Capital = 402.2 / (374.8 - 0.0) = 107.3%
Clearly, a +100% organic return on invested capital is far more impressive. In general, firms that can deliver high returns on capital from organic means are more attractive investments than those that have grown through acquisitions.
In addition to this, firms with little or no goodwill will not face surprise "goodwill impairment" charges that artificially reduce earnings per share, making their P/E multiples look worse than they otherwise would.
To whittle down the current Magic Formula stock universe to just the companies that grow primarily through organic means, I've calculated the firms where goodwill and intangibles represent less than 10% of total assets. These represent the current MFI stocks that are least affected by the strategy's ignorance of the "acquisition penalty":
0.0%: Aeropostale Inc. (ARO)
0.0%: Lorillard Inc (LO)
0.0%: Protein Design Labs Inc (PDLI)
0.0%: Pre-Paid Legal Services Inc. (PPD)
0.0%: TeleNav, Inc. (TNAV)
0.0%: Seagate Technology (STX)
0.2%: USA Mobility Inc (USMO)
0.3%: ZST Digital Networks Inc (ZSTN)
0.5%: SanDisk Corp (SNDK)
0.6%: SuperGen Inc (SUPG)
1.5%: China North East Petroleum Holdings Ltd (NEP)
1.9%: Cardiome Pharma Corp (CRME)
2.7%: Power-One, Inc. (PWER)
3.1%: Western Digital Corp (WDC)
3.4%: Motorcar Parts of America Inc (MPAA)
3.9%: Sino Clean Energy Inc (SCEI)
3.9%: Impax Laboratories Inc (IPXL)
5.4%: Garmin Ltd (GRMN)
5.5%: Veeco Instruments Inc (VECO)
7.3%: Teradyne Inc. (TER)
7.4%: Intel Corp (INTC)
7.6%: Forest Laboratories Inc. (FRX)
8.9%: EarthLink Inc (ELNK)There you have it, a list of firms with truly great returns on invested capital and a penchant for growing through internal means instead of buying it up at high prices - in most cases. Investors should still do their own due diligence. Firms like Seagate have written off large portions of bad acquisitions in the past (e.g., the Maxtor deal), and Intel has made recent purchases that are not yet reflected in their financial statements (e.g., the acquisition of McAfee (MFE)).
On the other side, here are the top 10 MFI stocks with the highest amount of goodwill as a percentage of total assets. These are your "serial acquirers", whose wheelin' and dealin' nature should be scrutinized before investing into them:
74.7%: United Online Inc (UNTD)
68.6%: Visa (V)
67.1%: Deluxe Corp (DLX)
67.0%: Amedisys Inc (AMED)
63.6%: Lender Processing Services Inc (LPS)
63.3%: Reynolds American Inc (RAI)
61.4%: New Energy Systems Group (NEWN)
54.1%: Almost Family Inc (AFAM)
52.2%: Raytheon Co. (RTN)
52.2%: ManTech International Corp (MANT)
Disclosure: Steve owns AFAM, VECO, WDC, SNDK