GuruFocus Premium Membership

Serving Intelligent Investors since 2004. Only 96 cents a day.

Free Trial

Free 7-day Trial
All Articles and Columns »

Is Apple, Inc. (AAPL) Still a Good Investment?

December 28, 2010 | About:
10qk

gurufocus

354 followers
Apple, Inc. (AAPL) is certainly one of the most rewarding stocks in the last decade. With one of the best CEOs around and the fanciest products, the price of Apple stock has grown from $7.5 in 2003 to $326 today. An interesting question to ask today is: Is Apple stock still a good investment?

It seems to be. Apple is the portfolios of 21 gurus we track, mutual fund and hedge fund types alike. Among them, Mark Hillman bought 70,072 shares in the quarter that ended on 09/30/2010, which is 4.62% of the $431 million portfolio of Hillman Capital Management. Daniel Loeb bought 150,000 shares in the quarter that ended on 09/30/2010, which is 4.46% of the $954 million portfolio of Third Point, LLC. Andreas Halvorsen bought 269,000 shares in the quarter that ended on 09/30/2010, which is 0.83% of the $9.24 billion portfolio of Viking Global Investors LP. David Einhorn owns 837,500 shares as of 09/30/2010, an increase of 168% from the previous quarter. This position accounts for 5.91% of the $4.02 billion portfolio of Greenlight Capital Inc. Steve Mandel owns 2,707,106 shares as of 09/30/2010, an increase of 20.26% from the previous quarter. This position accounts for 6.75% of the $11.39 billion portfolio of Lone Pine Capital. George Soros owns 247,584 shares as of 09/30/2010, an increase of 13.43% from the previous quarter. This position accounts for 1.05% of the $6.69 billion portfolio of Soros Fund Management LLC.

During an interview with Charlie Rose, David Einhorn, one of the best hedge fund managers of our time, answered the question from Charlie about Apple:

Charlie Rose: So you like Apple.

David Einhorn: Very much. Apple is an interesting company because it has arguably one of the best brands in the country. It's growing at an enormous rate. And the growth effectively feeds on itself because when you buy one Apple product, you want to buy another because they're so nicely compatible. The result is that businesses, which for a generation essentially avoided Apple products, are adopting them now because of the demand from the employees. They come in with their iPhones and they say, "I want you to support this with my e-mail." That's a powerful growth story. With the introduction of the iPad, it's sort of reaching a critical mass right now.

It is no doubt that Apple has had the greatest growth. As seen in the 10-year financials of Apple, its revenue has grown 30% a year in the last decade:



On the top of that, its profit margin grew 20% a year, thanks to its brand building and name recognization.



Compound with both of the revenue growth and the expansion of profit margin, its earnings grew 60% a year in the past 5 years. Therefore it is not surprising that the stock has appreciated many times during the past decade.

With a market cap of close to $300 billion, second only to XOM, if Apple stock price does what it did in the last dcade. It would be a trillion dollar stock. Wish US government has a few of that.

So how is Apple evaluated by the market? Is it overvalued?

If we plug AAPL into our DCF Calculator, and use the half of the earnings growth rate of Apple Inc. over the past 5 years, it shows that AAPL has a fair value of about twice of what it is now. But remember, this assumes that Apple will deliver 30% earnings growth every year in the next decade.

If we look at the 10-year valuation history of APPL, we get the chart below:



If we click on the legend of the chart in the 10-year valuation page, we get where the prices are relative to historical P/E bands:

apple_10yv_pe.JPG

We can see that the stock price of Apple is closer to its 10-year low P/E of 16, and relative far from the 10-year P/E high of 41. So it seems to be at its low end of valuation as measured by P/E.

If we hide the P/E and P/B bands by clicking on the legend of the 10-year valuation chart, we get where the stock prices relative to historical P/S band:

apple_10yv_ps.JPG

Because of the profit margin expansion, the price of APPL is at the high end of the historical valuation, while the P/E is at the low end of the historical valuation.

So is Apple stock expensive?

With what we observed from the DCF calculator and the historical valuations, AAPL seems to be fair-valued if the growth trend in the revenue and profit margin continue in the future years. What is the probability for that to happen? We don’t know. If we look at the history of Apple as a company, the role of its CEO Steve Jobs is one of the most important factors in the company’s growth. Thinking all of these, an interesting question to ask is, would you believe that we will see the first trillion dollar ($1,000,000,000,000) company in the next decade?



About the author:

gurufocus
GuruFocus - Stock Picks and Market Insight of Gurus

Rating: 3.7/5 (19 votes)

Comments

cranium
Cranium - 3 years ago
Due to the continued growth of the iPhone and of course the brand new iPad, Apple's YOY growth has been in the 70% (with earnings slightly outpacing revenue) the last couple of quarters. With worldwide smartphone growth just starting to hit the mainstream and new carriers still in the offing, huge iPhone growth is assured for the next 24 months.

The great multiplier though is iPad, this product didn't even exist at the beginning of 2010 so this pure gravy to an already impressive growth engine. Consider that iPad was expected by many to only sell 1 million units in 2010, and now several estimates put 2011 units at over 40 million. The competition basically hasn't even arrived yet and Apple has the 2nd version of the product due to be released at the end of calendar Q1. The added bonus is that once exposed to the "Apple ecosystem", new customers invariably start buying other products are thus the 'Halo effect" breeds further growth. 2011 and 2012 will be huge years for Apple, to keep the growth going beyond that will require something like the rumored holographic TV, but for me it's 2011 and 2012 currently has my undivided attention.
AlbertaSunwapta
AlbertaSunwapta - 3 years ago
I sold APPL and then bought it back after I realized the potential for the iPad. The cash in the bank is a huge drag but adds considerable comfort.

An iPad is still on my wish list too. Most of the comparisons with smaller screen competitors miss the point that in terms of viewing area the iPad is a significant percentage larger which all of us who have moved up from 15" monitors on our PCs.
halis
Halis - 3 years ago
I'm not a fan of scenarios where if a company stumbles once, they can lose half their value. Apple could very well keep growing at that rate. But I think Android definitely levels the playing field for the iPhone as well as the iPad.

But I am not a growth investor and I don't know how to calculate growth rates for any company for 10 years. My family owns a few businesses and if someone asked me to calculate their growth in revenue and profit for 10 years, I would have no idea.

I am not a growth investor. I prefer companies who are trading low enough, that even if they remain completely stagnant for 10 years, you have a significant margin of safety to protect against the downside. And yes these types of stocks exist right now.
AlbertaSunwapta
AlbertaSunwapta - 3 years ago
Just because Apple is a growing company one shouldn't look away from it to find value. What matters is the price you pay and the cash flow(s) you'll eventually be able to take out of it.

Like Microsoft of the early 90s, which consolidated the operating system and the major application softwares under a common 'language' that system administrators were comfortable with, Apple today is consolidating the users needs around a common 'language' they are comfortable with. It's essentially making the migration of a lot of day to day computing exercises seamless and relatively hassle free compared to using multiple devices and software designs. Google is doing the same.

Please leave your comment:


Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names | Earn affiliate commissions by embedding GuruFocus Charts
GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to $400 per referral. ( Learn More)
Free 7-day Trial
FEEDBACK