1) Identify two publicly traded stocks of the same company at different prices.
2) Short the high-priced shares (X) and buy the low-priced shares (Y). Pocket X-Y.
3) Sell Y and buy X when the price of X and Y are equal.
Hubbell Inc. (HUB.A) (HUB.B) fits the bill. Hubbell manufactures and distributes electrical products and lighting used in residential, commercial and industrial applications.
My broker, IB, indicates there’s ample liquidity to short at least 1,000 shares today.
Hubell has 7,167,506 A-shares and 52,775,144 B-shares with equal cash-flow rights.
Hubbell buys back its B-shares.
|Ticker||Current price||Voting rights||Comment|
|HUB.A||$ 46.5||20 votes||Market cap of $ 3.2B.|
|HUB.B||$ 53.0||1 vote|
Historical spread of HUB.B versus HUB.A.
[ Enlarge Image ]
So why do stocks with identical cash-flow rights trade at different prices?
1) The different classes are owned by different groups. Different groups behave differently causing short-term discrepancies. This is the case with Berkshire’s A-shares versus Berkshire's B-shares.
2) Even though voting rights alone do not generate cash income, investors are sometimes willing to pay a premium for super-voting shares.
3) One class of shares may be included in an index while the other is not. This causes index-funds to temporarily bid up (or down) one class while the other is ignored.
Though there are examples of gaps persisting for decades, more often than not, a double-digit spread will close within a year. Research indicates the prices of all dual class shares will at some point reflect the underlying cash-flow rights.
Disclosure: This is not a recommendation to buy, sell or short anything. I had no position in any of the stocks mentioned at the time of writing.
Idea 1 - Lennar: [www.gurufocus.com]