WSJ Market Beat noted that even ECRI’s own weekly leading index (WLI) came in at 122.5 with the latest reading, the highest since early September. However, ECRI said it relies on the longer-term WLI (see chart below) when it made the dreaded "R" call over two months ago. (The long-term WLI is available only to ECRI's paying clients, but the chart below was posted at The Big Picture via Jim Bianco on December 9.)
The bottom line is that ECRI says its recession call still stands. Lakshman Achuthan, co-founder of ECRI, said in a Bloomberg TV interview (clip below) on December 8 that
“This one [downturn] is persisting. Give us a year, and you'll see if we are right on our recession call."
|Chart Source: The Big Picture via Jim Bianco, 9 Dec. 2011|
Wall Street obviously has an entirely different view from the ECRI.
The chart below from the Bespoke Group shows the Intrade contract betting on whether the US will go into a recession in 2012. For the contract to pay out, U.S. real GDP would need to be negative for two consecutive quarters. Right now, the odds of a recession in 2012 are at 38.2% based on actual monetary bets, down from a high near 50% in early October, as U.S. economic data has gotten much better since.
|Chart Source: Bespoke Group, Dec. 9, 2011|
For now, we'd agree with Achuthan when he remarked, “You’re not going to know whether or not we’re wrong until a year from now.” Only time will tell if ECRI or Wall Street has the brighter crystal ball.