10-year

10-Year Anniversary Promotion (20% off)

Join GuruFocus Premium Membership Now for Only $279/Year

Once a decade discount

Save up to $500 on Global Membership.

Don't Miss It !

Free 7-day Trial
All Articles and Columns »

Are You Kidding Me, FCX?

April 14, 2012 | About:
Chandan Dubey

Chandan Dubey

99 followers
I am increasingly finding myself at a loss to describe what I feel after reading the proxy of Freeport-McMoran Copper & Gold (FCX).

I started getting interested in the stock in October 2011 when the stock price dropped precipitously to $28.85. The immediate reason was Indonesian labor strike at Grasberg. There were violent fights between unionized and un-unionized workers and the mine had to be closed at the expense of loss in production. Coupled with a jittery market the stock dropped to a level not seen since Jul 2010.

I have been seeing people trumpet FCX as a very good investment with upsides ranging from 40% to 65%. There has been numerous articles on seeking alpha for example (see here for a few).

FCX is a miner, smelter and refiner of copper, gold and molybdenum. Copper is the main source of revenue and represents nearly 80% of the revenue. The company produced 3.9b pounds of copper in 2010 and has proven reserves 120.5b pounds. FCX owns mining and smelting operations in North America, South America, Indonesia and Europe. Due to high prices of these commodities since 2004 the revenue of the company has increased quite a bit. But the company sells commodities and a drop in spot prices will have dire effects on the operating profit of the company.

Now that we have a brief idea of what FCX does, let us look at the valuation of FCX. The company has very small debt. The market cap at the moment is $35B and the EV is $38B. It has consistently generated good FCF and the figures are as follows.

200320042005200620072008200920102011
FCF (in $B)0.4330.2001.4101.6064.4700.6622.814.8614.086
Income (in $B)0.1820.2020.9951.4572.977-11.0672.7494.3364.560
RoIC6.226.2546.5669.3823.57-73.4422.9728.6325.03


We see that the figures were abysmal before 2004 and jumped suddenly in 2005. The FCF is not as stable as one will like it to be, but the improvement has been impressive. The RoIC has been quite elevated since 2004.

Insiders

Following are the main people on the board.

  • Richard C. Adkerson (age 65) has been Director, President and CEO since 1995.
  • James R, Moffett (age 73) has been chairman of the board since 1995.


Compensation

Now I am ready to tell you why I have been disturbed after reading the proxy statement of this company. Let us look at the compensation practice of this company. To keep the figures in picture, the company has generated around $4.3B in net income in 2010 and $4.5B in 2011.

Let us first look at the benefits the management will get if they are fired or resign for “good reason”. A “good reason” includes failure of acquirer to to provide the executive with substantially the same position. What this means is that if the company is acquired and the CEO does not get the CEO position then he can leave the job and receive the sum entitled to him.

Now let me put this in words. The company will pay the CEO $428m in case he is not offered the CEO job if the company is acquired (by Dec 31, 2010). He will get $300m if he leaves the job for some “good reason” or is fired. Think of this for a moment. The company was making around $200m in total income before 2004. Due to some changes in the program the lump sum has been reduced materially and the proxy also lists the figure for April 2011. If the whole board walks out in case of acquisition of the company by April 2011, the total payment would be $518m.

U2ZMm1NgKbYLrtvUu7-B7RWlERAY4AueijGgjvXv

If this is not egregious enough, let us look at the compensation of the board and the management.

IEbEi_V8whP_CHLBcwFNl1TeZS-1XqLdYdGV6vea

qv8qlz66Y7lfZqGLuHzQLLIJh5ye56rSWZRdluE5

In 2008 when the company made a loss of nearly $11B, the CEO received $77m in compensation. I ask you, what kind of performance based incentive is that?

It is quite obvious that FCX started performing better when the commodity prices took a sharp upturn in 2004. Before this period the company was average at best and achieved 6% RoIC with around $200m in net income. How much is the spot prices of Copper being affected by the CEO of the company ? Why does he get to keep so much of the shareholder’s money when he has made no discernible impact on the profitability of the company. How does the board justify the compensation of the management as well as the supervisory board itself ? Since 2002 the share count has gone from 293m to 995m and the shareholders are poorer because of the stock based dilutions and additional stock offerings in 2007. The company has also bought back shares worth of $500m in 2008. From the company’s new releases in 2007.

Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. (FCX) announced that it has completed $5.76 billion in equity financings, through the sale of 47.15 million shares of common stock at $61.25 per share

These offerings generated net proceeds, after underwriting discount and expenses, totaling $5.6 billion, which will be used to repay indebtedness incurred in connection with the acquisition of Phelps Dodge Corporation.
[i][/i]Only 7 months later in Dec 2007 the company announced a share buyback of 20m shares and increased dividends. This is management at its best. The news releases do not give me enough information to make an informed judgement on this turn of fortune of FCX in 7 small months but I do not want to waste any more time on a management with such a skewed way of “managing the company for the shareholders”. This is a company in which the management is clearly on the other side of the table from its shareholders.

I will be staying away from this company for a long time to come.

About the author:

Chandan Dubey
I invest because I want to be free by the time I reach 40 years of age i.e., 2025. My investment style is to find a small number of bets with large margins of safety. I pay a lot of attention to management and their incentive. Ideally, I like to buy owner operator businesses. I am fortunate to have a strong inclination towards studying. I aid my financial understanding by extensive reading in psychology, economic, social sciences etc.

Rating: 4.7/5 (51 votes)

Comments

pravchaw
Pravchaw premium member - 2 years ago
Management is certainly more interested in padding their own nests not benefiting the shareholders.
johnheiderscheit
Johnheiderscheit - 2 years ago


Does anyone know of a fund or ETF that has a strategy of shorting this type of managment team. Maybe screen for managements making more than x% of company gross profit AND delivering subpar ROEs and/or ROICs?
cdubey
Cdubey - 2 years ago
@Johnheiderscheit This is really not a good idea. Shorting a bucket of stocks is going to be very dangerous. I will not buy FCX, but I will not short it either. If the commodity prices take off again, there is a significant upside.
dhago
Dhago - 2 years ago
Really helpful summary on FCX which I own. The proxy certainly revealed unconscionable management practices. Are you aware of any shareholder activist group that one could email to begin to focus other shareholders on this to pressure management to do the right thing? Thank you for your analysis.
cdubey
Cdubey - 2 years ago
Sadly, no. I think investors should come up with a website where they can get together and talk about these issues, especially management pay. I notice that most shareholders ignore the pay part of the proxy. Even if they care, it has so many components and such arbitrary way of measuring performance that it is near impossible to figure out what is going on. Even if a lone voice is raised, it cannot do much.

We need an activist website which everyone will know about. It will help investors of a particular company to vote against the wishes of the management, if they find it detrimental.
Cogitator99
Cogitator99 - 2 years ago
Good points. Thanks Cdubey.
BostonKev
BostonKev premium member - 2 years ago
Thanks for the article. I owned FCX briefly and dumped it at a tiny profit a couple if years ago. I will not touch it again.

Please leave your comment:


Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names | Earn affiliate commissions by embedding GuruFocus Charts
GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to $400 per referral. ( Learn More)
Free 7-day Trial
FEEDBACK