I assume that most of my readers are familiar with Joel Greenblatt’s “You Can Be a Stock Market Genius.” Despite the cheesy title it’s an excellent book, so read it if you haven’t already! A common theme in the book is that whenever there is a situation with a forced seller there is a potential opportunity. And while the government is not truly a forced seller, they are definitely happy to get rid of AIG as fast as possible as long as it can report a profit to the tax payer. Selling tens of billions worth of stock without negatively impacting the share price would seems quite an accomplishment.
AIG itself is one of the largest buyers when the U.S. government is selling. It bought $8 billion worth of stock this year already and intends to buy another $5 billion in the current public offering. Since AIG is selling at a big discount to book value these buybacks have a meaningful impact on the book value per share. The company is currently trading at approximately $33.00, representing a 45% discount to the $60.58 book value per share reported last quarter. The Q2 Financial Supplement contains the following table:
Since June 30 AIG bought 98.36 million shares on August 3 for $30.50 per share and the company has agreed to buy 153.8 million more shares in this months offering for $32.50 per share. This would bring the total common shares outstanding to approximately 1.476 billion and AIG’s shareholders’ equity to $96.7 billion for a book value per share of approximately $65.51. That’s a lot of (book?) value creation a short time frame!
ValuationWhile I have had AIG on my watch list for months I have been hesitant to buy a position because it isn’t easy to fully understand it. The latest 10-K is more than 400 pages long and contains a lot of detailed information about reserves, discount rates, credit exposure and all kinds of other things I don’t really know enough about to understand what kind of impact it has or could have on future profitability.
The question is of course how important details are compared with the big picture. Just as with any other company, you can look at higher level statistics such as book value, earnings and return on equity. The fact that historically stocks with a low P/B, low P/E or low P/FCF ratio have outperformed the market supports the view that the big picture determines the value for a large part.
Bruce Berkowitz’s thesis, whose firm is betting big on AIG, also doesn’t provide a lot of insight beyond the high-level view. They assume that AIG will be able to earn a 10% return on equity and simply is worth book value because of that. I usually don’t spend a lot of time thinking about relative valuations, but seeing that other US insurers trade close to book currently is reassuring. The 10% is a number that AIG itself is also targeting, and based on the historical earnings (close to $10B annual) of Chartis and SunAmerica, the two core assets of AIG, it doesn’t seem to be an unreasonable target. AIG is facing some headwinds though: Low interest rates hurt profitability, and they are also facing increased regulatory oversight. That might not be too bad though if it prevents another 2008-like screw up.
InsidersI’m less worried about bad corporate governance with a large cap company than with an obscure micro cap, but I think it’s nevertheless important to take a look at what insiders own and what they are doing. Most of AIG’s management is new since 2009 and as a group they own very little of the company: just about $25 million worth of shares, mostly because they get paid a big part of their salary in shares. If I would correctly be thinking that AIG is undervalued, why wouldn’t insiders be buying shares?
WarrantsAn interesting alternative to investing in AIG common stock is purchasing the warrants (ticker: AIG-WT) that were issued in the beginning of 2011 as a part of the recapitalization of AIG. They expire in January 2021, have a strike at $45 and unlike regular options they are adjusted downward in case of a dividend:
If AIG is able to grow book value at a 10% rate the next decade, and is trading at book value at that point in time the warrants could provide some awesome returns. After nine years BV would be approximately $153. With the warrants trading at $14.6 and having a $45 strike this would be close to a 640% return or an 23% annualized return. The common stock would return "just" 340% or 15% annualized. But since AIG is probably going to pay a dividend soon the return is going to be a bit lower since the strike price is only adjusted for dividends in excess of $0.675 yearly (would probably lower the annualized return with almost a percentage point).
The initial exercise price is subject to anti-dilution adjustment for certain events, including (i) future stock dividends, distributions, subdivisions or combinations; (ii) the issuance of below market rights, options or warrants entitling the holder to purchase AIG common stock for a period of sixty days or less; (iii) dividends or other distributions of capital stock (other than AIG common stock); rights to acquire capital stock, debt or other assets (subject to certain exclusions); (iv) per share cash dividends in excess of $0.675 in the aggregate in any twelve-month period; and (v) certain above-market issuer tender offers for more than 30 percent of the then-outstanding AIG common stock.
While I do think warrants are attractive it’s not a bet I’m comfortable making because it’s also adding leverage the opposite way. Lets assume that the market is valuing AIG correctly right now – and that’s something I always see as a very real possibility – and the next decade the company is able to grow value at 8% a year. If you hold the shares you still come out ahead with an 8% annualized return, but if you own the warrants you get less than 6%. And somewhere between a 6% and 7% growth rate you start losing money with the warrants. That kind of range of outcomes doesn’t really look that superior to me than the common stock.
ConclusionI have been thinking a long time about buying AIG knowing that I would be buying something that I can only understand from a high level perspective, but finally decided to buy some shares because it seems that the company is undervalued and creating a lot of value by buying back shares in large numbers. Despite this the share price went down this week when the Treasury announced another public offering and that AIG would be buying $5 billion more in shares. I thought that this week would be as good a time as any to jump on board.
DisclosureAuthor is long AIG shares