DST Improves Corporate Governance, But Problems Linger
DST said Hooley is CEO effective September 12. He had worked at State Street Corp. for 11 years before January 2004, when he became president and CEO of Boston Financial Data Service, Inc., a joint venture between State Street and DST. In 2009 Hooley became president and COO of DST.
He takes the reins during a time of high turnover. DST said McDonnell, who had formerly performed the duties of board chairman without having the official title, will serve as non-executive chairman “through his planned retirement” on December 31. He isn’t the only one to go. Board directors Thomas A. McCullough and William C. Nelson said February 6 this year that they wouldn't stand for re-election at the next annual shareholders meeting. Audit committee chairperson M. Jeannine Strandjord told DST Systems Inc. on April 2 this year that she would quit, explaining that she also served as a board director at another company whose policy limited her ability to continue to serve simultaneously at DST. As Strandjord and Nelson had both been with DST for 16 years and McCullough for 22 years, their familiarity with the management could easily have compromised their ability to supervise objectively, so their exit is positive for the company’s balance of power.
In an indication that McDonnell’s powers had few limits, his compensation in 2010 was well over four times the median for the other named executive officers, and it also had disproportionately outpaced that of other officers at DST. This as well as other red flags had contributed to DST’s financial results giving it an AGR ® score of 8 a few months ago, when we had warned that DST has higher accounting and governance risk than 92% of comparable companies. With no full disclosure yet about how Hooley will be compensated as CEO, as well as some improvement in other areas, DST had an AGR score of 40 as of August.
Nonetheless, the new management faces lingering problems. For example, the board still includes 77-year-old A. Edward Allinson, who has served on DST’s board since 1995 after taking a pause from an earlier stint between 1977 and 1990.
The decisions that DST managers have made in the past continue to have impact. While the company managed to lower its debt burden by $145.9 million in the second quarter to more than $1.21 billion as of June 30, this debt continues to exceed DST’s total equity. DST undertook a number of acquisitions in 2011, ranging from the retirement planning information firm Newkirk that May to the asset management solutions provider ALPS Holdings Inc. that October. The amount DST paid above book value for its acquisitions was $484.9 million as of June 30, or nearly 14% of total assets, compared to nearly 10% of assets as of Sept. 30, 2011. If McDonnell and his team estimated those deal values incorrectly, the new management will have to announce painful revisions to DST’s earnings later.
Even so, DST’s stock price gained nearly 5.4% compared to Wednesday to trade at around $55.21 per share at Thursday's close of the market. In the coming years, those investors will see whether Hooley’s long familiarity with DST and State Street will help or hinder his ability to instigate cultural changes.