-Shane Battier, in a post game interview last Thursday after hitting six 3-pointers to help the Heat win game 7 over the Spurs to take their second straight NBA title. Battier used that tongue-in-cheek quote to respond to a question from Doris Burke on how he was able to turn around his performance. He was benched in numerous games during the post season in large part because of his poor performance. That changed in game 7.
I felt like Shane Battier on Thursday when I saw EBIX’s stock drop over 40% in one day. It then dropped another 25% Friday morning as panic and forced selling took over after the announcement that a Goldman Sachs subsidiary was backing out of the deal to buy EBIX at $20.50 per share. I felt lucky because I was interested in investing in Ebix as a merger opportunity that I felt actually had potential for upside. I wrote this article on a few similarities between Dell and EBIX, but fortunately never got around to buying shares in EBIX as I was more interested in other ideas. So obviously I was lucky there. However, I most likely would still be holding shares and maybe adding if I owned EBIX. And I chose to initiate a small position Friday around $8.75 per share.
(Note: it’s a small position. Why? Because I generally run a diversified basket approach to investing in these types of stocks. I choose to mitigate risk through diversification at the portfolio level. This allows me to own numerous undervalued securities with problems but also with asymmetric risk-return profiles. What this means is that on balance, I think there will be more winners than losers and the amount of the winners will exceed the amount of the losers. It’s similar to the insurance underwriting business. Having said that, Ebix might be one of the losers. I have no idea. But I do believe the stock is dramatically mispriced in one direction or another).
So I think that at $20, the stock is (was) cheap. At $10, it’s completely mispriced.
As Jamie Mai (of Cornwall Capital and Big Short fame) has pointed out with various investments, sometimes stocks are either worth $0 or worth $20, but not $10. I think that’s the case here. The market doesn’t know how to price Ebix at the moment, so it sits on the fence until uncertainty is resolved. I think this is an opportunity for value investors, as long as they understand the risk.
Beware the RiskThe risks are very real, and due to brevity, I’ll simply link to the shorts’ ideas which I found very detailed and thorough. As far as I know, they may be right. But I have a few reasons to think they may be wrong as well. But in a situation like this, it is very helpful to study the risks.
The Ebix debacle started with this article on seeking alpha from over two years ago. There were a few other articles on Seeking Alpha that shed light on the potential problems at EBIX. The thesis basically revolves around the accounting practices at the firm, which some feel are hiding certain liabilities and also evading certain corporate income taxes. Read all the posts for details. Then earlier this year, another short poster wrote this research piece on why he thinks EBIX is a fraud. The latter poster has also written follow up pieces. It also helps reading through the comments in each of the pieces. You have to sift through a lot of useless comments, but you’ll find a few that are from very knowledgeable sources. For a counterpoint to the above theses, check out this post.
EBIX—Cheap and Good?I have been following EBIX since coming across it a number of months ago in Greenblatt’s Magic Formula screen. I won’t go into too much detail here, but just wanted to describe some of my own thoughts on EBIX.
It’s a company that sells software and e-commerce solutions to insurance companies. They provide back office solutions for these companies with the goal of improving the efficiency of their customer’s operations. They also provide services to banks, financial advisors, and other corporate clients. They have a widely diversified customer base with (according to EBIX) a recurring revenue base of around 80%. This means many of the customers continue to buy the products and services on a repeat basis, providing steady and stable cash flow for Ebix.
This recurring revenue along with the low fixed costs needed to operate the business (leading to very high free cash flow, high gross margins, and above average returns on capital) are what I like most about the EBIX business model. On the surface, it appears to be an outstanding company. Check out the 10-year financials... high margins, high returns, and growing sales and cash flow:
So the company appears to be generating really good results. The kind of results that typically would demand premium valuations. However, after the nearly 60% price reduction, you can buy this company at roughly these single digit valuations:
- EV/EBIT: 5
- P/E: 5
- P/FCF: 5
- EV/EBITDA: 4
I got lucky again because shortly after I completed my purchase, the company announced that it approved a $100 million buyback. At the Friday valuation, this represented close to 30% of the outstanding shares. The announcement felt like a reaction to the negative headlines more than a thoughtful business decision, but nevertheless, I think a buyback makes tremendous sense at these valuations.
Think about this: the company generated around $70 million of free cash flow in the last 12 months. At that rate, it could buy back the entire value of the company in about 5 years.
One of the short theses is that the company will face serious tax consequences that may lead to significantly higher tax rates and/or significant tax penalties. Let’s assume EBIX has to pay the $100 million penalty (I have no idea where the short poster got this number), it could pay back the penalty in 18 months using its own free cash flow. Let’s further assume that EBIX is levied with a new tax rate that causes taxes to go up and reduce free cash flow by 30%. In that case, EBIX might make $50 million in free cash flow. So it will take maybe 24 months to pay off this hypothetical tax penalty.
Of course, these are wild guesses from both the short poster and myself. Penalties could go much higher, but they might also not be nearly as bad. The market is assuming they will be very bad. But my experience is that in many cases like this, the downside is already priced in. The business model has been very successful, and the company is producing real cash (as opposed to juiced earnings but negative free cash as was the case with many frauds of the past like Enron, Worldcom, etc…).
CEO Owns Large PositionAnother reason I don’t think that EBIX is a complete fraud and going to $0 is that the company’s CEO Robin Raina owns about 10% of the outstanding stock. Raina is an entrepreneur who transformed EBIX’s business a decade ago. He has a large portion of his net worth tied to EBIX stock. With around $40 million personally riding on the fortune of the company, I doubt that we will see EBIX become worthless. Again, this is opposite of many frauds of the past where we saw many insiders selling in droves as their stock approached new highs on the back of record earnings (but large negative free cash flows).
To Sum it UpEbix is an interesting situation. I decided it warranted a small position. You might wonder why I decided to write 1,300 words on a stock that represents such a small portion of my portfolio. One is that most stocks I own are hated for one reason or another and represent individually, very small portions of the portfolio, as I mentioned above. This style of investing is one of three main strategies I use in my portfolio.
The other reason I commented on this stock is simply because it’s a widely scrutinized situation that I find interesting. I think the upside is significant for the stock, but the risks are real so you mitigate those by using a basket approach with other similarly undervalued stocks.
I am glad that I avoided the huge downdraft, and like Shane Battier said, “sometimes it’s better to be timely than good.” I also think that we might see a reversion to the mean in this stock, similar to Battier’s reversion to the mean performance in game 7. It will be interesting to watch either way. Hopefully watching the EBIX outcome will be as much fun as the Spurs-Heat were in the NBA finals this year.
Full Disclosure: I own shares of DELL and EBIX.
Please remember that this post does not represent a recommendation to purchase shares of any of the securities mentioned. It is also not a comprehensive report on any of the stocks mentioned. Please do your own due diligence to reach your own conclusions. I have no idea of your personal financial situation. Investing has certain risks that may not be suitable for you.
About the author:
By using separate accounts, Saber offers its clients complete transparency and liquidity (the funds are held in the name of the client and cannot be accessed by the investment manager). Saber looks to partner with like-minded clients who are interested in a patient, long-term approach to investing that is rooted in the principles of value investing.
I also write at the blog www.basehitinvesting.com.
I can be reached at [email protected]