Pope Brar is a money manager based on the West Coast who has spent a considerable amount of time analyzing the success (as well as the failure) of some of the greatest investors.
Brar has carefully examined the records of such legendary investors as Warren Buffett (Trades, Portfolio), Seth Klarman (Trades, Portfolio) and others to see what they have done to achieve such success over such a long time in the equity market.
- Warning! GuruFocus has detected 4 Warning Signs with BAC. Click here to check it out.
- BAC 15-Year Financial Data
- The intrinsic value of BAC
- Peter Lynch Chart of BAC
Brar had worked as an analyst and investment bankers and using the knowledge gained from his research, he opened his own fund last year after first seeding it with his own capital for five years to make sure he could achieve the superior results he desired.
When asked about his investing approach, Brar said, “One of the best ways to achieve elite returns over a long period is to purchase businesses that are selling for less than half of intrinsic value. Buffett invested in two major categories. Plan A is always to buy the Coke and Moody's of the world at 50 percent off. If you buy these types of businesses at that discount and it takes 2-3 years to trade at intrinsic value, you'll do very well. Intrinsic value will be much higher in 2 to 3 years. So 50 cents may be worth $1.30 or $1.40. This is always Plan A. But plan A is virtually impossible to execute across the entire portfolio because they are so very, very rare. When plan A fails, go to plan B. Plan B is to buy at half off, regardless of business quality (as long as you're pretty sure intrinsic value is very unlikely to decline.)”
As he says, Plan A is difficult to achieve because it can usually only be found when we have a full on market meltdown like in 2002 or 2008 that creates extraordinary values. However, as asset-based deep value investors, we can combine the concept of steep discounts from intrinsic value as well as a discount total asset value to find some potentially outstanding opportunities.
For intrinsic value, we can use the Benjamin Graham number, which uses a theory developed by Graham to determines the intrinsic value using both earnings and asset values. When reverse engineering Graham's theory, we can establish that the book value (multiplied by 22.5) and multiplying that product by the earnings per share, we have a rough estimate of a firm's ongoing intrinsic value (note that this is not Mr. Brar's methodology, but a 'quick and dirty' way for us to get an approximate fair value of the company).
It is then a simple matter to screen for stocks trading at half of this value and also trade at a discount to asset value (again note that these are not Mr. Brar's picks, but the results of a stock screener using his theories and approach).
The two REITs are probably going to combine under a takeover offer made by BPY for BPO. It is a share for share offer, so with BPO trading at a discount, BPY investors can back into what will be a world class portfolio of commercial real estate including huge chunks of downtown Manhattan.
Bond insurer MBIA (MBI) also shows up as a potentially severely undervalued stock.
The company has spent the past several years cleaning up the mess it made during the mortgage meltdown and arguing with banks, most notably Bank of America as to who owed who what for the massive losses that were incurred. The company has a lot house cleaning to do so it can get back to its core municipal bond insurance business, but if they are successful, the potential upside for current levels is nothing short of spectacular. The stock trades at about 70 percent of book value and one third of the company's Graham number.
Harvest National Resources (HNR) is also on the list.
The company has reached an agreement to sell its interest in an oil and gas partnership in Venezuela and is attempting to sell its interests in Gabon in Indonesia. If all the transactions are concluded successfully, the stock would have an asset value of more than double the current stock price with most of that in cash.
There are obstacles when dealing in nations with less-than-friendly governments, but insiders seem confident and deal will get done as officers and directors have been pretty big buyers of the stock in the last three months. The stock currently trades at about 40 percent of book value and one third of its Graham number, so the shares are definitely cheap.
Combining intrinsic value and book value to find stocks with the potential for huge gains makes a lot of sense. Although you can certainly use other methods, the Graham number proves to be a decent representation of intrinsic value and is usually within 10 percent or so of the values uncovered using more sophisticated valuation models.
Tim Melvin is a value investor, money manager and writer. He has spent the last 27 years in the financial services and investment industry as a broker, adviser and portfolio manager. He has also written and lectured extensively on the markets with his work appearing on RealMoney.com, DailySpeculation.Com as well as several print publication including Active Trader and the Wall Street Digest. Learn which 3 low risk, high yield stocks Tim owns for the trade of the decade.