Starcore: A Profitable Gold Miner Trading Below Book Value

Author's Avatar
Jul 09, 2014
Article's Main Image

1 The Company

Starcore International Mines (SHVLF, Financial) operates the San Martin mine located in Mexico. The deposit contains both gold and silver and has been mined continuously for more than 20 years.

Number of shares 143,390,465
Number of warrants 18,745,000
Fully diluted share count 162,135,465
Share price $0.16
Market cap $22.4 million
Enterprise $13.42 million
P/E 3.30
P/B 0.50
P/S 0.71
Tickers SHVLF, TSX:SAM

The stock is currently trading at a very low P/E ratio.

1.1 History

Starcore acquired its only operational gold mine, San Martin mine, from Goldcorp in 2007. The San Martin mine has produced over 550,000 gold equivalent ounces since 1993. Earliest reports estimate that 250,000 tonnes grading 15g Au/t and 100g Ag/t were extracted between 1900 and 1924 from the San Martin mine.

D49VVvLrHGDQ2d-9IagnNtQLt94Qnd4WxUIR4rquUgJtNi1ANopOnatacnzUdL7-p6SVTrWY9mFYzpMZN5omXUutCDKnMO78Yf58BK5Yq-Z0-Lp054ZTt_KZEq2Wdh20HQ

(Source: Investor presentation)

2 Management

The CEO Robert Eadie has 20 years of industry experience. Robert Eadie has been with Starcore since October 2003. Collectively, Starcore's team has over 100 years of industry experience.

2.1 Compensation

Here is a table of Starcore management's annual salaries for the year ending July 31, 2013:

Name Title Annual Salary
Robert Eadie CEO C$240,000
Gary Arca CFO C$180,000
David Gunning COO C$180,000

_YbKU5eYgzH1BfQQyxByeMNgJcpVzQgpn9LP6y0ykydzVwScLtenmL7v2muY6CcrZ8GI_W3pMSvpbglPwJM8KXNl8XPz-VrMs4txwd8KVi55pNMNSd-3ZG0fbsnQVF9eaw

(Source: Annual General Meeting)

I believe the management compensation is reasonable for this size of company. Here is a table of directors' compensation for the year ending July 31, 2013.

DVAprNheGgxCaXkksJ6Yfiz4CbyhQWgdGJm70jzkUhKkUMf6IDOWCvq2xXOdgXehPv6Sp-PEnd_Dpe4m8wwKmo4K9GKgbpJ_uY0kWabPYIXvAgL6SD2Nr4RanpfEzAOtng

(Source: Annual General Meeting)

Again, very modest compensation for the board.

2.2 Insider Ownership

As at July 7, 2014, Starcore’s directors and senior officers held a total of 2,699,700 shares or 1.9% of the company. The CEO, Robert Eadie, has been buying shares at the open market this year and last year. This year he purchased 95,000 shares at C$0.155 on May 30. Robert Eadie currently holds 2,284,000 shares or 1.6% of the company. There have not been any insiders selling the shares since 2012 when the stock peaked at C$0.45.

3 Operating Summary

Here is a table of Starcore’s annual gold production since 2007:

Year Annual Production oz. Eq. Au
2007 29,606
2008 21,367
2009 21,696
2010 18,156
2011 23,736
2012 19,213
Jan 31 2013 - Jan 31 2014 26,304
Jan 31 2014 - April 30 2014 5,338

The annual gold production has averaged 22,868 ounces since 2007.

4 Financial Summary

4.1 Current Situation

Starcore reported the fiscal 2014 third-quarter, which ended April 30, financial results on June 12 with the following highlights:

Revenue C$8.3 million
Net income C$1.2 million
Cash C$9.8 million
Debt C$0
Gold production 5,338 ounces
Mine operating cash costs $833 per ounce
All-in sustaining costs $1,066 per ounce

The fiscal 2014 third-quarter results were short of Starcore’s internal target for the quarter, but the company outperformed the previous year's production.

4.2 Historical Developments

Here is a table Starcore’s revenue and EPS since 2007:

Fiscal Year 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Revenue (C$ millions) 18.5 27.1 24.1 23.2 39.5 57.0 30.2
EPS (C$) -0.06 -0.04 +0.02 -0.05 -0.05 +0.11 +0.03

Starcore became debt free in September 2013, which should help the earnings going forward.

5 Shares

Here is a table of Starcore’s number of shares since 2007:

Fiscal Year 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Number of Shares (millions) 36.7 60.7 60.7 74.5 88.0 139.8 143.4

The number of shares has increased significantly since 2007. I don’t expect the number of shares to grow substantially from here on since Starcore is currently profitable and debt free. Starcore has 18,745,000 warrants outstanding at an average exercise price of C$0.23.

6 Outlook

Starcore expects to continue to operate the mine over an expected mine life of at least 6 years. The mine has maintained two years of reserves for the past seven years. The mine development team has been replacing more ounces than Starcore mines on a year-to-year basis. The San Martin mine has been successfully replacing reserves for the past 20 years. Starcore is also working to become a dividend-paying corporate entity.

dw4PaMzBVl5km5liY5EjSMxPbmrcBLq1GNfmf99CeE6tvykw8agJeQxP9Jt4aVCCeUcMILxJnot6aX85o18hxWIOLNUQpcgPWHMe2uluiyU2lo2IraMc_WzlavwAKqwV8A

(Source: Investor presentation)

7 Risks

I believe the two main risks are the price of gold and relatively low gold reserves. Starcore’s all-in sustaining costs were $1,066 per ounce in the most recent quarter compared to the current gold price of $1,320 per ounce. Starcore’s current gold reserves last only for two to three years. Starcore is a penny stock.

8 Conclusion

Starcore is currently trading at a P/E ratio of 3.3, P/S ratio of 0.7, and P/B ratio of 0.50. I believe Starcore could have at least 100% upside potential during the next 12 months.

S--rh6F3BaaMoWpYXTg20zAAc05T_uW-uDUalC-5Stp_Ndc12Ke_lbyG95_zV0SkohidL50Yxq01CLcm4DAJvROv7Kw4WeFZIqDUmf-_M6TQNifx3k55dfFueQYKNBHh9A

(Source: Investor presentation)

Disclosure: The author is long TSX:SAM.