1. How to use GuruFocus - Tutorials
  2. What Is in the GuruFocus Premium Membership?
  3. A DIY Guide on How to Invest Using Guru Strategies
Ravi Nagarajan
Steve Alexander
Articles (5983)  | Author's Website |


September 04, 2009 | About:

In the previous article, Debt in Business Analysis, MagicDiligence did an overview of analyzing a prospective investment's debt burden. In this article, we'll go through a Magic Formula example that covers a lot of the bases: Deluxe Corporation (NYSE:DLX). Before we begin, it's important to set a context for analyzing the debt. Is this a heavily cyclical company that suffers huge swings in revenue and profitability over short periods of time, or does it have fairly stable sales and profit margins? What is the near and medium term prospects for earnings growth? These are both important points - cyclicals and declining businesses obviously are riskier if they have worrisome debt burdens.

Deluxe's main business is printing and selling checks. This is a fairly stable business - even in poor economic times, folks still have mortgages and utility bills that they often pay with checks. A look at the financial statements confirm this: Deluxe's revenue has never experienced more than a single-digit percentage change in any of the past 5 years, and profit margins have been relatively predictable. However, checks as a payment method are also declining as online bill pay and debit cards become more popular, with check volume declining 4% annually this decade. The financials also confirm this: Deluxe's annual revenue growth since 2004 is minus2% per year, and operating profits down 9% annually, with operating margin declining from 22% in 2004 to just under 16% today. So, while Deluxe is a fairly stable business, it's also a declining one and will continue to be.

Let's start by getting an idea of Deluxe's cash resources, as this is what's needed to service, and eventually pay off, the debt. The company has about $18 million in cash on the balance sheet. Trailing 12-month free cash flow (cash from operations - depreciation) is about $177 million. However, about $51 million of this is paid back to investors via Deluxe's hefty 6.3% dividend yield. So, if we're interested in the nice yield being maintained, this should be subtracted out of free cash flow. So, total available cash resources are about $144 million over the next year.

Total "short-term" cash resources = $144 million.

Now we move on to short-term debt liabilities. There is $75 million classified as "short-term debt" on the balance sheet, and digging into the notes we see this is a line of credit the company uses for short-term cash flow purposes (it is not revolving and thus does not cost much in interest). In addition to this, there is about $500k in capital leases due this year, so total debt to be cleared this year will be about $76 million.

Total "short-term" debt coming due = $76 million.

So far, so good, so let's move onto long-term debt. The balance sheet lumps everything together into a total $743 million of long-term debt obligations. Again, we need to dig into the "Notes" section to get the breakdown. If a large portion of this "long-term" debt is due next year, for example, we might want to consider lumping it into the "short-term" section. However, Deluxe's earliest maturation is about $280 million in 2012, with the rest due in 2014 and 2015, so we'll leave it alone for now.

However, this long-term debt (all bonds, by the way) carries interest on it. The "Notes" section shows that about $200 million of it carries a 7.4% rate, while the rest carries a low 5.1% rate. This interest adds up to about $49 million a year (from the income statement). We need to add that into our total short-term debt burden.

Total interest on debt to be paid this year = $49 million.

Add up all the debt-based payments to be made in the next 12 months and we get $125 million. We then compare this against the roughly $144 million in cash resources over the next 12 months. That's tight - the cash-to-debt ratio is about 115%. The absolute minimum MagicDiligence likes to see is 150%, and that's with a very stable business. Deluxe is experiencing declining sales and profit margins, meaning we can't be confident of the cash resource number - it may very well go down. In that case, the first action will be to cut the dividend, and the dividend is one of the few attractive qualities of an investment in Deluxe.

So, you can see why MagicDiligence holds a negative opinion on Deluxe as a Magic Formula investment - management is cutting things a little too tight given the uncertainty in future earnings levels.

This is a useful exercise to go through when debt levels look a little high when examining financial statements. Of course, a company with no debt doesn't require an exercise like this, nor does one with little debt relative to cash on the balance sheet and free cash flows. In any case, a process like this is often employed when MagicDiligence looks for Top Buy picks on the Magic Formula screen.

Steve Alexander


About the author:

Steve Alexander
Ravi Nagarajan is a private investor and Editor of The Rational Walk website. Ravi focuses on applying value investing techniques to find securities trading well below intrinsic business value. Ravi has over 15 years of experience in the financial markets and started investing on a full time basis in 2009. From 1996 to 2009, Ravi held a number of technical and executive level positions in the commercial software industry. Ravi graduated Summa Cum Laude from Santa Clara University with a degree in finance. Visit his website The Rational Walk

Visit Steve Alexander's Website

Rating: 2.9/5 (12 votes)


Batbeer2 premium member - 7 years ago
Thank you for your example. A clear analysis. I have a question though.

>> The absolute minimum MagicDiligence likes to see is 150%.

Do you agree that on balance PAYX requires less cash for it's daily operations than say.... BNI ?

If so, do you have any thoughts on how to take this into account ?

I consider both stable.

Please leave your comment:

GuruFocus has detected 4 Warning Signs with Deluxe Corp $DLX.
More than 500,000 people have already joined GuruFocus to track the stocks they follow and exchange investment ideas.

Performances of the stocks mentioned by Steve Alexander

User Generated Screeners

toshi23Quality Growth
pbarker46Short % < 2,PE10 <30
nuno.a.pomboEstatiscal Low Priced Stocks
hugHigh Piotroski
hugHigh Piotroski & Low EV/REBITD
pbarker46Shiller USA
BoubaOCF Size 1
jesusgnDividend consistent
Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names | Earn affiliate commissions by embedding GuruFocus Charts
GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to $400 per referral. ( Learn More)