10-year

10-Year Anniversary Promotion (20% off)

Join GuruFocus Premium Membership Now for Only $279/Year

Once a decade discount

Save up to $500 on Global Membership.

Don't Miss It !

Free 7-day Trial
All Articles and Columns »

It’s good to have NRG. NRG Energy looks cheap right now.

December 28, 2009 | About:
NRG Energy, Inc. is a wholesale power generation company, primarily engaged in the ownership and operation of power generation facilities and the sale of energy, capacity and related products in the United States and internationally. The Company has a diverse portfolio of electric generation facilities in terms of geography, fuel type and dispatch levels. It seeks to maximize operating income through the efficient procurement and management of fuel supplies and maintenance services, and the sale of energy, capacity and ancillary services into attractive spot, intermediate and long-term markets.

At today’s close of $24.21 NRG shares are down significantly from their 2007 and 2008 highs of $47.20 and $45.80. Earnings can vary widely with competing energy pricing and the effects of hedging activities. There is not a clear view of what to expect. Here are the current EPS views (on continuing operations) for 2009 and 2010 from three different and respected sources…





2009 Estimate


2010 Estimate


Value Line


$3.55


$2.74


Yahoo Finance


$2.86


$2.08


Zacks


$2.74


$2.11




Even at the low-end expectations NRG now trades for< 8.9x this year’s and under 11.7x next year’s earnings. If the high-end materializes the multiples would be 6.8x and 8.8x respectively.

Here are the more detailed per share numbers from continuing ops as reported by Value Line:



Year


Sales


C/F


EPS


B/V


Avg. P/E


Range


2004


13.56


2.13


0.81


13.05


15.4x


9.00-18.10


2005


16.76


1.56


0.33


11.20


NMF


15.10-24.70


2006


22.98


4.49


1.82


19.35


13.4x


20.90-29.70


2007


25.30


4.95


1.95


19.35


20.1x


27.20-47.20


2008


29.38


6.87


3.66


26.56


9.4x


14.40-45.80




It is noteworthy that NRG shares changed hands as high as $29.70 - $47.20 in both 2006 and 2007 when earnings were well below both today’s trailing and next year’s expected EPS. Clearly there is big upside potential for buyers at the current quote.

Morningstar rates NRG at 4-stars (out of 5) and sees ‘fair value’ as $37.00 /share. Standard and Poors also assigns NRG 4-stars (out of 5) and carries a 12-month price target of $30 /share.

Here are two ways to play NRG using buy/writes for about 5 ½ and/or 24 ½ month time horizons.





Cash Outlay


Cash Inflow


Buy 1000 shares NRG @$24.21 /sh.


$24,210




Sell 10 June $25 calls @$2.15 /share




$2,150


Sell 10 June $25 puts @$3.00 /share




$3,000


Net Cash Out-of-Pocket


$19,060






On the June 18, 2010 expiration date…

If NRG rises to at least $25 (+ 3.3% from today’s price):

· The $25 calls will be exercised.

· Your shares will be sold for $25,000.

· The $25 puts will expire worthless.

· You will be left with no shares and $25,000 in cash.

· You will have no further option obligations.

That would be a best-case scenario net cash-on-cash profit of $5,940/$19,060 = 31.1% achieved in under six months on shares that only needed to rise by 3.3% or better.



What’s the downside?

If NRG remains below $25 on the June 18, 2010 expiration date:

· The $25 calls will expire worthless.

· The $25 puts will be exercised.

· You will be forced to buy another 1000 shares.

· You will need to lay out an additional $25,000 in cash.

· You will end up with 2000 NRG shares.

· You will have no further option obligations.



What’s the break-even on the whole trade?

On the original 1000 shares it’s their $24.21 purchase price less the $2.15 /share call

premium = $22.06 /share.

On the ‘put’ shares it’s the $25 strike price less the $3.00 /share put premium

= $22.00 /share.

Your overall break-even would be $22.03 /share. NRG could fall by as much as $2.18 (or -9%) without causing a loss on this trade.



Unless you see NRG going down more than 9% by mid-June the risk/reward here looks very good.



Long-term traders consider this more aggressive buy/write combination…





Cash Outlay


Cash Inflow


Buy 1000 NRG @$24.21 /share


$24,210




Sell 10 Jan. 2012 $30 calls @$3.70 /share




$3,700


Sell 10 Jan. 2012 $30 puts @$8.70 /share




$8,700


Net Cash Out-of-Pocket


$11,810






If NRG goes up to $30 or higher (+ 24%) by the Jan. 2012 expiration date…

· The $30 calls will be exercised.

· You will sell your shares for $30,000.

· The $30 puts will expire worthless.

· You will be left with no shares and $30,000 in cash.

· You will have no further option obligations.

That would result in a best-case scenario net profit of $18,190/$11,810 = 154% cash-on-cash.

Not too bad for a minimum move of 24% over a 25.6 month holding period.



What’s the downside?

If NRG remains below $30 through the Jan. 2012 expiration date…

· The $30 calls will expire worthless.

· The $30 puts will be exercised.

· You will be forced to buy another 1000 NRG shares.

· You will need to lay out an additional $30,000 in cash.

· You will end up with 2000 NRG shares.

· You will have no further option obligations.



What’s the break-even on the whole trade?

On the original 1000 shares it’s their $24.21 purchase price less the $3.70 /share

call premium = $20.51 /share.

On the ‘put’ shares it’s the $30 strike price less the $8.70 /share put premium = $21.30 /share.

Your overall break-even would be $20.91 /share or (-13.6%) below the trade inception price.

Summary: In this longer-term trade you have maximum upside of 154% on any move of + 24% or greater while you are protected against loss on any drop of less than 13.5%.



Disclosure: Author is long NRG shares and short NRG options.

About the author:

Dr. Paul Price
http://www.RealMoneyPro.com
http://www.gurufocus.com/peter_lynch.php
http://www.TalkMarkets.com
http://www.MutualFunds.com

Visit Dr. Paul Price's Website


Rating: 3.2/5 (9 votes)

Comments

sth143
Sth143 - 4 years ago
Dr. Price,

Nice research and read. This gem continues to be undervalued and the the earnings have been depressed for lack of a better term because of their hedging activities. Those are just my two cents.

partlow
Partlow - 4 years ago
Caveat Emptor!

The potential return calculations are erroneous (i.e. overstated) as they neglect to consider Federal Reserve mandated minimum margin requirements for the sold puts.

It is unfortunate that Guru Focus does not have better quality control screening mechanisms in place.

Jeff Partlow
Dr. Paul Price
Dr. Paul Price premium member - 4 years ago


Margin requirements can be met simply by having adequate 'marginable security' in paid-up stocks, t-bills and bonds in your margin type account.

The indicated returns clearly state they are 'best-case scenario' and 'cash-on-cash' returns that assume the puts expire worthless and the calls are exercised.

Dr. Paul Price
Dr. Paul Price premium member - 4 years ago


Note:

There were three insider buys on NRG in early November against no sells. A total of 8500 shares were purchased at an average price of $23.52 /share.

AustrianValueFreak
AustrianValueFreak - 4 years ago


Does anyone know why Buffett is selling NRG ?
Dr. Paul Price
Dr. Paul Price premium member - 4 years ago


NRG Energy will replace Sun Microsystems in the S&P 500 after the close of trading on a date to be announced : Sun Microsystems (JAVA) is being acquired by S&P 100 & 500 constituent Oracle (ORCL) in a cash deal expected to be completed soon, pending final approvals.

superguru
Superguru - 4 years ago
Getting attractive. Are you guy still bullish on NRG after this quarter results?
superguru
Superguru - 3 years ago
Anyone following NRG. It came up on my radar after a year.

I have a small tracking position on this which I am thinking of eliminating at small loss. I have been getting more and more concentrated over last 6 months (which hopefully means I am getting less ignorant.)

Please leave your comment:


Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names | Earn affiliate commissions by embedding GuruFocus Charts
GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to $400 per referral. ( Learn More)
Free 7-day Trial
FEEDBACK