1. How to use GuruFocus - Tutorials
  2. What Is in the GuruFocus Premium Membership?
  3. A DIY Guide on How to Invest Using Guru Strategies
Thomas Macpherson
Thomas Macpherson
Articles (184)  | Author's Website |

Nintai Investments 1st Quarter 2019 Returns

In our first public report, we discuss returns, winners and losers, thoughts on eating our own cooking and our views on corporate giving

With the opening of Nintai Investments LLC, we are going back to our previous method of reporting quarterly returns to the GuruFocus community and readers of our website’s blog. Before I get into the specifics, a few ground rules are in order.

  • As professional investment managers, we will not be providing a full list of portfolio holdings. Our customers pay us to allocate their dollars in a specifically chosen portfolio – not announce their portfolio to website readers.
  • Returns are a composite of the Hayashi Trust and individual investor portfolios.
  • Inception date is Oct. 15, 2018, for the Hayashi Trust and Jan. 1, 2019, for individual portfolios.
  • In my previous life, I was happy to discuss individual holdings and my rationale for their being in the portfolio. As paid investment managers, we must necessarily be far more discreet in our answers to readers’ questions.
  • Of course, past performance does not promise future returns. Any company discussed will be identified as a portfolio holding of an individual investment account, the Hayashi Trust or my personal brokerage account.

As many of you know, I ran the Nintai Partners Portfolio – and then the Charitable Trust – from 2002 to 2015. In addition, I was a portfolio manager from 2015 to 2018 at Dorfman Value Investments. While very proud of those returns, the results of Nintai Investments LLC must stand on their own and develop their own unique history. Going forward, when I discuss the Nintai Investments LLC portfolio, I refer to a composite of individual portfolios managed by Nintai Investments LLC and the Hayashi Trust portfolio managed by Nintai Investments LLC. Also, most statemements will use the pronoun "we" because I have staff who assist me at both Nintai Investments LLC and the Hayashi Trust.

We were pleased with the first-quarter performance of the composite portfolio. It outperformed its benchmark, the S&P 500. We are also pleased with performance since inception. Below are the numbers for periods ended March 31, 2019.

Total returns net of fees

We added two new positions in the first quarter. Making a return to the portfolio was F5 Networks (NASDAQ:FFIV). We sold out of the entire position in 2018 when the company’s stock price hit 155% of our estimated intrinsic value. Total profit was 44% on the position, which we held in the portfolio for roughly 19 months. Year to date, the stock has dropped roughly 8%. After reviewing the company, we increased our estimated intrinsic value by 35%.

The second purchase was PetMed Express (NASDAQ:PETS). The company had been on my watchlist for four years. Over the past year, the company's stock price dropped by 50%. Free cash flow has grown by 14% annually over the past five, years while earnings have grown by 18% over the same period. The stock yields 5.2%. There have been questions around whether the company has been selling Tramadol (a synthetic opioid pain medicine) to animal veterinarians to be sold or prescribed illegally for human use. To date, there has been no announcement of any investigations to support such an allegation.

This quarter we sold our entire stake in Allergan (NYSE:AGN) following an announcement that the company was being investigated for systematically overcharging the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid (CMS) by using false data on average wholesale pricing (AWP). As we wrote at the time, this is a particularly egregious crime that steals money from the patients who can afford it the least and reduces government funding available for other treatments. We simply will not tolerate such behavior by a holding’s management.

During the quarter we also added to four existing positions. Each holding was trading at a significant discount to my estimated intrinsic value at the time I added to the position.

Winners and losers

Two stocks led the way in quarter one – Veeva Systems (NYSE:VEEV) and NIC (NASDAQ:EGOV). Veeva rose 38% in the quarter while NIC increased by 34%. Veeva’s February quarterly earnings exceeded both top and bottom lines. Management upped guidance as well. Over the last year, VEEV has increased free cash flow by 33%, earnings per share by 60% and revenue by 24%. We increased Veeva’s estimated intrinsic value by roughly 13% in February 2019 after the company raised guidance. The position is currently up 115% since it was purchased in February 2018.

NIC recovered nicely after the markets recognized the loss of part of the company’s Texas website contract was not going to have a significantly adverse effect on the firm. Free cash flow grew by 1% after analysts estimated a 15-20% drop in 2018. While the quarter’s results were gratifying, the position is currently only breaking even. While Veeva and NIC had great quarters, we should point out that roughly half the portfolio holdings were up 20% or more during the quarter.

It wouldn’t be value investing if you didn’t have to report on stocks that were the inverse to those winners. We all know them. The ones that get you all puffed up and make you feel like the smartest person in the room. First, for the second quarter in a row, the largest drag on the portfolio was Biosyent (BIOYF), down 5.2%. The company was a having a decent year until the last days of the first quarter. Management announced that they received two notice of deficiencies from Health Canada for their two new cardiovascular products. The company has exclusive distribution rights to these drugs in the Canadian markets. At the time of this report, we are still in discussions with Biosyent management, Health Canada clinical reviewers and market analysts to judge the impact on our estimated intrinsic value.

Portfolio characteristics

The current Abacus view as of March 31, 2019, shows that the Nintai Portfolio holdings are roughly equal with the S&P500 and projected to grow earnings at a significantly greater rate than the S&P500 over the next five years.

The additions of F5 Networks and PetMed Express along with the sale of Allergan brought the portfolio to 21 positions in total. If opportunities arise, we will add or reduce position size. We might also swap out an entire position for a chance to invest in a situation with a better risk-reward profile. We are uncomfortable having the valuation of the portfolio be equal to or slightly higher than the S&P500. This explains the build-up in cash to roughly 20-25% over the quarter. We will be actively looking to take profits or find cheaper prospects over the next six to nine months.

We remain highly focused in industry and sector weightings. We have holdings in only five of the S&P500’s 11 categories: financial services, technology, industrials, consumer defensive and health care. Industrials and consumer defensive are both miniscule holdings, while roughly 90% of holdings are in only three categories: financial services, technology and health care.

However, we should point out that we see the categorization of the portfolio slightly differently. For instance, Computer Modelling Group (CMDXF) is categorized as a technology company by the index. But, with 100% of its revenue derived from the oil and gas discovery process, we consider the company a way to gain exposure in the energy industry.

Thoughts on turnover and cash

Turnover for the quarter was roughly 14%. We expect this to drop as assets under management increase. We try to look for turnover of roughly 5-10% annually. This is dependent of course on factors such as overall market performance (steady increases over the past few years have allowed me to take profits but also increase turnover) or individual stock performance (a sudden price drop of 20% might make for a compelling buy scenario).

We have reached the upper end of stocks we look to own in the portfolio. It’s likely that most trading going forward will be additions or subtractions from existing positions. Occasionally opportunities may arise where we swap out an entire position for one that is trading at a steeper discount to my intrinsic value and that represents a step up in quality and potential long-term gains.

In regard to cash, the portfolio currently maintains roughly 20% of its assets in cash. We have been fortunate that 80% of the portfolio has easily outperformed 100% of the S&P500. How long that can continue is anybody’s guess. With the Abacus report showing the portfolio’s estimated five-year earnings growth at 18% greater than the S&P500 while being equally valued, the data suggest that there is at least a moderate chance this could continue. As always, past performance does not ensure future returns.

Eating our own cooking (Tom's personal comments)

As many of my readers may remember from my GuruFocus presentation in April 2016, I have the “honor” of having an extremely rare genetic mutation (the TRNT1 gene for those keeping track). This disease – known by its acronym SIFD – is found in only 18 individuals in the world. While my parents always told me to be different, I’m not sure this is what they meant!

I bring this up because over the past eight years of treatments I spent my entire life’s savings seeking care that would keep me alive (the U.S. is both a great place and a terrible place to have a rare disease). Now that we’ve isolated the disease through modern genetic clinical research, I’m in the position to begin rebuilding my individual investment portfolio. I want to assure my readers and investors that every dollar invested will be in the same stocks we own in the Nintai Investments portfolio. It is my intention that I will most certainly be eating my own cooking.

Making a difference

At Nintai Investments, we take our social responsibility seriously. We (meaning myself and my shareholders) currently give 10% of net income to charitable causes that are making a difference in our communities. Each annual report will highlight an organization that Nintai Investments has supported that year. As a corporate citizen, Nintai Investments has an equal – if not greater – responsibility to make a difference in our society. Having lived an immigrant life here in the U.S., I have seen that capitalism produces enormous opportunities for all our citizens. But sometimes that isn’t enough -- sometimes people need a helping hand. Having been blessed with a wonderful family, a great education and a successful professional career, I feel Nintai Investments has a special responsibility to help provide that helping hand.

[email protected]


My best wishes for a wonderful spring season.

About the author:

Thomas Macpherson
Thomas Macpherson is Managing Director and Chief Investment Officer at Nintai Investments LLC. He is also Chairman of the Board at the Hayashi Foundation, a Japanese-based charity serving special needs children and service pets. The views expressed in his articles are his own and not necessarily those of the firm. He is the author of “Seeking Wisdom: Thoughts on Value Investing.”

Visit Thomas Macpherson's Website

Rating: 5.0/5 (7 votes)



Kurshumov95 - 10 months ago    Report SPAM

This is wonderful

Thomas Macpherson
Thomas Macpherson premium member - 10 months ago

Thank you Kurshumov95.

Dernek - 10 months ago    Report SPAM

Thank you for providimg us with your reports. I enjoy reading them imensely. I wish you good luck.

Thomas Macpherson
Thomas Macpherson premium member - 10 months ago

Thank you Dernek. That means a great deal. I'm glad you enjoy them. - Tom

Please leave your comment:

Performances of the stocks mentioned by Thomas Macpherson

User Generated Screeners

pascal.van.garsseHigh FCF-M2
kosalmmuseBest one1
DBrizanall 2019Feb26
kosalmmuseBest one
DBrizanall 2019Feb25
MsDale*52-Week Low
Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names | Earn affiliate commissions by embedding GuruFocus Charts
GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to $400 per referral. ( Learn More)
/* */