US Market Remains Significantly Overvalued Despite Trade War Fears

Stock market falls from near all-time highs, yet Buffett's favorite market indicator remains above 140%

Author's Avatar
May 10, 2019
Article's Main Image

On Friday, the day U.S. President Trump increased tariffs on over $200 billion of Chinese goods from 10% to 25%, Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (BRK.A, Financial)(BRK.B, Financial) CEO Warren Buffett (Trades, Portfolio)’s favorite market indicator stood at 141.7%, down approximately 2.7% from its May 1 level of 144.4%.

Dow tumbles further on tariff hike

During the first hour of trading, the Dow Jones Industrial Average traded over 300 points lower than Thursday’s close of 25,828.36 on Trump’s tariff hike, sending the Dow down close to 700 points from last Friday’s close of 26,504.95.

1902293942.png

President Trump said in a tweet that he expects the tariffs to make the U.S. "much stronger" and that China "should not renegotiate deals" at the last minute.

Two major gurus show little trepidation regarding the trade war

CNBC columnist Kate Rooney said on Thursday that Leon Cooperman (Trades, Portfolio) and Mario Gabelli (Trades, Portfolio), two major investors, “are not worried about the ongoing trade war.” Rooney cited several reasons, including reasonable valuations, a “friendly” Federal Reserve and low recession risk.

Cooperman, who turned his Omega Advisors hedge fund into a family office at the end of 2018, said the ingredients for a recession are not present: The Federal Reserve remained “dovish” regarding the increase in interest rates while stock valuations remain “reasonable.”

Gabelli said that while it is time someone “arm-wrestles” the trade issue, the GAMCO Investors Inc. (GBL, Financial) CEO still hopes for a “better and fairer” resolution. Gabelli further said that Trump’s threat to increase tariffs and China’s ensuing retaliation represents “creative tension.”

Stock market remains significantly overvalued yet value screeners still identify good opportunities

The ratio of total market cap to gross domestic product, probably the “best measure” of market valuations according to Warren Buffett, stood at 141.7%, approximately 26.7% higher than the “significant overvaluation” threshold of 115%. Based on this market valuation level, the average market return per year over the next eight years is -1.90%.

1557500262903.png

According to the predicted and actual returns chart, the expected market return per year over the next years ranges from -9.70% in the most pessimistic case to 2.10% in the most optimistic case.

1557500401766.png

Despite the overvalued market, GuruFocus’ value screens still show strong investing opportunities as Table 1 illustrates. The value screener counts are as of Thursday.

Screener USA Canada UK Europe Asia Oceania Latin America Africa India
Graham Net-Net 232 58 53 260 659 11 10 14 51
Undervalued Predictable 58 6 56 123 73 8 48 7 12
Buffett-Munger 36 4 32 78 94 2 23 5 52
Peter Lynch PE 30 0 20 40 58 0 6 1 8
Peter Lynch PS 96 6 35 104 80 6 38 22 42
Peter Lynch PB 110 19 60 149 112 6 32 24 61
Lynch p2ebitda 171 8 50 188 119 8 16 17 54
Hist Low PS 34 2 17 53 104 0 16 6 33
Hist Low PB 47 3 29 71 110 2 30 9 29
Magic Formula 4456 541 2321 6976 13274 576 1104 384 3459
52-week Low 1130 127 422 1468 2875 108 379 151 1449
52-week High 1762 235 1196 2828 1413 187 537 108 396
3-year Low 535 79 197 689 1472 43 150 70 825
3-year High 1316 146 943 2015 708 129 431 68 232
5-year Low 382 49 134 466 964 26 92 56 491
5-year High 1187 139 905 1859 561 121 407 53 213
High Div Yield 57 5 10 129 42 16 25 6 6

Table 1

Disclosure: no positions.

Read more here:

Chevron Greenlights Anadarko to Buffett-Backed Occidental

Matthews Asia Small Companies Fund Buys 8 Stocks in 1st Quarter

Lyft Accelerates Ridership Revenue Despite Large 1st-Quarter Net Loss

Not a Premium Member of GuruFocus? Sign up for a free 7-day trial here