Hide

FocusBar

Subscribe to Premium Member

Model Portfolios

Can we invest based on the gurus' recent stock picks and holdings? What kind of returns can we expect if we invest based on the consensus picks of gurus or the bargain candidates and the stocks many of them hold? What kind of returns can we expect if we buy the top-ranked stocks?

In order to find out the answers to these questions, we have constructed a few model portfolios based on different criteria. Click on the charts to find out the details and holdings for each of them.

Guru Strategies:

All numbers do not include dividends.
YearS&P 500Consensus Picks Portfolio Guru Bargains Portfolio Most Broadly Held Portfolio Most Weighted Portfolio
2007 4.2% -5.5% 9.7% 16.2% -1.7%
2008 -38.9% -30% -45.7% -49.1% -34.2%
2009 24.7% 30.7% 48.1% 34.4% 41.5%
2010 11.6% 14.6% 6% 15.3% 15.4%
2011 -0% 0.5% -8% -23.8% -15.8%
2012 11.5% 17% 13.6% 18.6% 2.8%
2013 18% 18.4% 29.4% 25.2% 22%
Screener LinksScreener HereScreener HereScreener HereScreener Here

Value Strategies:

All numbers do not include dividends.
YearS&P 500Buffett-Munger Screener top 25 Top 25 Undervalued Predictable Companies Top 25 Historical Low P/S Ratio Companies Top 25 Historical Low P/B Ratio Companies
2009 24.7% 28.6% 55.7%
2010 11.6% 19.5% 20.2% 16.4% 19%
2011 -0% 6% -3.3% -1.9% -2%
2012 11.5% 12.1% 5.3% 17.6% 17.8%
2013 18% 11.5% 12.8% 13.6% 16.5%
Screener LinksScreener HereScreener HereScreener HereScreener Here

Value Strategies:

All numbers do not include dividends.
YearS&P 500Top 25 Historical High P/S Ratio Companies Top 25 Overvalued Predictable Companies
2010 11.6%
2011 -0% 9.4% 2.1%
2012 11.5% 4% 10.7%
2013 18% 20.8% 17.8%
Screener LinksScreener HereScreener Here

Buffett-Munger Screener top 25: Buffett-Munger Screener top 25

Top 25 stocks from the Buffett-Munger Screener, 1. These companies are undervalued based pe/g ratio. The portfolio consists of the top 25 most undervalued on the day of rebalance.

Top 25 Undervalued Predictable Companies: Top 25 Undervalued Predictable Companies

Top 25 Undervalued Predictable Companies screened from here. These companies have the best predictabilities, and their stock prices are undervalued in term of pe/g ratio. g is the average editda growth rate of the last 5 years.

Top 25 Historical Low P/S Ratio Companies: Top 25 Historical Low P/S Ratio Companies

Top 25 Historical Low P/S Ratio Companies. These companies have been very predictable in their business operations. Their sales and earnings have consistently grown for at least the past decade. However the price/sales (P/S) ratio of each of these companies is less than 30% above its historical low. The current list of stocks that meet this criteria can be found here.

Top 25 Historical Low P/B Ratio Companies: Top 25 Historical Low P/B Ratio Companies

Top 25 Historical Low P/B Ratio Companies. These companies have been very predictable in their business operations. Their sales and earnings have consistently grown for at least the past decade. However the price/book (P/B) ratios of each of these companies is less than 30% above its historical low. . The current list of stocks that meet this criteria can be found here.

Consensus Picks Portfolio: top 25 consensus new picks

These are the top 25 consensus picks of the Gurus during the most recent quarter. The rank is based on the number of the gurus who bought the stock. All other things being equal, the stocks that the gurus bought in higher concentrations (percentage of portfolio) are ranked higher. The portfolio is updated every 12 months. The current list of stocks that meet this criteria can be found here

Guru Bargains Portfolio: top 25 bargains on the day of portfolio update

Top 25 portfolio from Guru Bargains at the time of rebalance. The current list of stocks that meet this criteria can be found here

Most Broadly Held Portfolio: 25 most broadly held stocks

These are the most broadly held 25 stocks in Gurus' holdings. The rank is based on the number of the gurus who hold the stock. All other things being equal, the stocks that the gurus hold in higher concentrations (percentage of portfolio) are ranked higher. The portfolio is updated every 12 months. The current list of stocks that meet this criteria can be found here

Most Weighted Portfolio: 25 most weighted stocks

These are the 25 stocks with the most heavily weighted positions among the combined holdings of the Gurus. The rank is based on the combined positions of the stocks in the Gurus holdings. For instance: if Guru A holds 17% of WMT in his holding, and Guru B holds 5%, and Guru C holds 4%,the combined weighting is defined as 17+5+4=26. The portfolio is updated every 12 months. The current list of stocks that meet this criteria can be found here

Top 25 Historical High P/S Ratio Companies: Top 25 Historical High P/S Ratio Companies

Top 25 Historical High P/S Ratio Companies. These companies have predictable business, but traded at historical high P/S ratios. The purpose of this portfolio is to show that over-valued stocks appreciate less than the undervalued ones.
For details, see New Model Portfolios: Overvalued Stocks

Top 25 Overvalued Predictable Companies: Top 25 Overvalued Predictable Companies

Top 25 Overvalued Predictable Companies. These companies have predictable business, but are over valued as measured by DCF model. The purpose of this portfolio is to show that over-valued stocks appreciate less than the undervalued ones.
For details, see New Model Portfolios: Overvalued Stocks

Hedged Portfolio - Undervalued vs. Overvalued: Hedged Portfolio - Undervalued vs. Overvalued

If one runs a portfolio by being long on the undervalued stocks and being short the same amount of overvalued stocks, the performance of the portfolio will be decided by the difference in the performances of the undervalued stocks and overvalued stocks. The shorted stocks serve as the market hedge, and the portfolio will be market neutral. The performances of the general market will not affect the returns of the portfolio.

The performance of this hedged portfolio is from the relative performances of the model portfolios of Undervalued Predictable Companies to Overvalued Predictable Companies.

Hedged Portfolio - Low P/S vs. High P/S: Hedged Portfolio - Low P/S vs. High P/S

If one runs a portfolio by being long on the undervalued stocks and being short the same amount of overvalued stocks, the performance of the portfolio will be decided by the difference in the performances of the undervalued stocks and overvalued stocks. The shorted stocks serve as the market hedge, and the portfolio will be market neutral. The performances of the general market will not affect the returns of the portfolio.

The performance of this hedged portfolio is from the relative performances of the model portfolios of historical low P/S ratios to the historical high P/S ratios.

Top 25 CEO Buys: Top 25 CEO Buys

Top 25 CEO Buys

Top 25 CFO Buys: Top 25 CFO Buys

Top 25 CFO Buys

Top 25 Insider Cluster Buys: Top 25 Insider Cluster Buys

Top 25 Insider Cluster Buys

Top 25 CEO Sales: Top 25 CEO Sales

Top 25 CEO Sales

Top 25 CFO Sales: Top 25 CFO Sales

Top 25 CFO Sales

Top 25 Insider Cluster Sales: Top 25 Insider Cluster Sales

Top 25 Insider Cluster Sales

Questions about how the Model Portfolios were constructed, please the articles listed at the left side menu..

Add Notes, Comments or Ask Questions

Comments

Batbeer2
ReplyBatbeer2 - 1 week ago
Hi Aninda,

The model portfolio simply reflects the result of the screener on January 1 of each year. At yearend, the portfolio is liquidated and the money is invested in the a new set of stocks.

BUT

A stock that was in the portfolio before and shows up in the screener on January 1, is left untouched. It is left to compound. One example is World Acceptance Corporation (WRLD). This stock was bought in 2009 and has been in the model portfolio ever since. The reason for this is that the screener has consistently "recommended" WRLD on January 1 of each year since 2009.

The newsletter does not generate ideas for the model portfolio. It's the reverse. Any stock in the model portfolio has been consistently profitable over many years. The newsletter is low-level analysis of the drivers of past profitability. This should help to understand the sustainability of profitability going forward.

Hope this helps.

Feel free to drop me a message if you have further questions about the newsletter, the portfolio or the screener. You can find my e-mail adress in the newsletter or on my profile on this site.
Abhunia
ReplyAbhunia - 1 month ago
Hi,
I am trying to understand how the annual rebalance on the gurufocus model portfolios works. Can you please explain how GuruFocus rebalances at the beginning of the year. For e.g. lets assume we start with 100K and there are 24 stock picks by year end in the Buffett-Munger newletter recommended for 2012, How does Gurufocus determine which stocks to sell from its existing portfolio and which ones to add in Jan?
Thanks for the assistance
Aninda (a premium member)
Cirros
ReplyCirros - 3 months ago
why is the return for the S&P 500 your showing 6.4% when the index is up according to CNBC and Morning Star is only up 5.2%
Zollaron
ReplyZollaron - 4 months ago
Bmachtig,
Port4olios
ReplyPort4olios - 4 months ago
Are you comparing total return for the portfolio with the price-only return for the S&P 500 in the performance section?
Gurufocus
ReplyGurufocus - 4 months ago
The model portfolios uses the top 25 stocks on the day of rebalances.
Use13usa
ReplyUse13usa - 4 months ago
What are the reasons for not adding TEVA and WDC to the Undervalued-Predictable Companies portfolio?
Use13usa
ReplyUse13usa - 4 months ago
Why was BIG not added to the portfolio even though it has a top three valuation and appeared on the November 2012 issue of the Buffett-Munger Bargain Newsletter?
Supersmatt
ReplySupersmatt - 4 months ago
##
Actually the problem may be that when you click on the excel download icon the data that comes out is different to the above (in fact there are 30 stocks in teh excel file, not 25 as above).
Supersmatt
ReplySupersmatt - 4 months ago
##
Why is the new portfolio above different to the results of the Buffet-Munger screener as of today? The screener currently outputs :
ATK
ANSS
ATRI
ATW
BBBY
BIG
BJRI
SAM
BKE
CRR
FCFS
FLIR
FOSL
GD
HSIC
HUM
JOSB
MTD
MTSC
ORCL
PNRA
RL
RAVN
RGLD
TSCO
TYL
VMI
WMT
WAT
WRLD
2008oak
Reply2008oak - 7 months ago
Is there a way to see the holdings of the Buffett-Munger portfolio for each year since it was started? All I see is the portfolio since the beginning of the year.
Gurulands
ReplyGurulands - 7 months ago
The percentage increase for CPRT is not accurate. It should be greater than shown.
Lwelch80
ReplyLwelch80 - 11 months ago
When I look at the cost basis of assets in the portfolio, the total adds up to 143783.43 vs. 100,000 reported on the portfolio. Can you help me understand why there is a difference in cost basis on these assets. Given the information provided above there is a 23.31% increase in the value of the portfolio.
Shb600
ReplyShb600 - 1 year ago
BF.A BF.B are the same company should be only one to be consistent
Gurufocus
ReplyGurufocus - 1 year ago
Tradingaccount03,

the equal weighting only applies to new stocks at rebalance. if a stock is still in the portfolio at rebalance, its weighting is not changed.
Tradingaccount03
ReplyTradingaccount03 - 1 year ago
just looked at the model portfolios again...I see. Similar to Max 7777's question...for those who wish to know...the portfolio selects the number of shares so that all constituents roughly have the same weightings at the start of each year... rgds
Tradingaccount03
ReplyTradingaccount03 - 1 year ago
Can you explain how you determine the individual weightings (initially and if there are any changes when you do the annual rebalance) for the model portfolio (use any as an example please).
Aspenhawk
ReplyAspenhawk - 1 year ago
As I Come late to the party, which stocks should I buy now ? Already bought ESI-GD-ITT-WRLD.
Donale
ReplyDonale - 1 year ago
John Wiley & Sons, Inc. is displayed in the Buffet-Munger Bargains Newsletter with a current price of $47.12.
In the Portfolio the Stockprice is lower ($44.4)
Same for ITT Educational Services Inc.

Is that becouse of the rebalancing on 1st january?
Ghr@hunter-rodwell.com
ReplyGhr@hunter-rodwell.com - 1 year ago
Why is that only 5 of the portfolios have outperformed, and those not by very much? Is the model broken?
Jeisen
ReplyJeisen - 1 year ago
June 27, 2011: Am I reading this correctly? - Your "short" strategy is actually up 13+% if you were long? -

Also, Dionex is not valued at $0.... it was purchased at a value of $118.50/share, per WSJ. (deal completed May 17, 2011)...so the short portfolio is even better that +13% YTD
Gurufocus
ReplyGurufocus - 2 years ago
Once a year only during the new year holiday.
Avadhut
ReplyAvadhut - 2 years ago
How frequently the stocks in the portfolio are changed?

Avadhut

www.analytics.net.in
L.novak
ReplyL.novak - 2 years ago
do you have a list of stocks selling below tangible book value? novaklawrence@yahoo.com
Harney246
ReplyHarney246 - 2 years ago
Please add Excel download option to this portfolio.

Thanks
Rckymtns
ReplyRckymtns - 3 years ago
this chart does not seem to reflect the buffett-munger screener but the midcap s&p 500
Superguru
ReplySuperguru - 3 years ago

Based on results, guru bargains seem more like guru mistakes. Though some of the stocks here may have strong upside going forward assuming worst is behind us.

I am new. How are other members using this screen?
Gurufocus
ReplyGurufocus - 4 years ago
fixed! sorry about that.
Dwiprut
ReplyDwiprut - 4 years ago
Gurufocus - Why can't I see the holdings in the model portfolios anymore? I used to be able to see the holdings, but now there is a link telling me to log in. However, I'm already logged in and following the link does nothing but bring me back to the home page.
Gurufocus
ReplyGurufocus - 4 years ago
This page has been updated, to add the tabs in charts. Two other model portfolios are added. One is for the Buffett-Munger Screener, the other is for Undervalued Predictable Companies.
Cm1750
ReplyCm1750 - 4 years ago
Can we have a 1 year chart of the most-weighted and broadest held stocks as of 12/31/07 so we can see how guru stocks did over the past year?
Stevehem
ReplyStevehem - 4 years ago
this is the portfolio which has the guru's largest aggregate holdings. The 'broadly held' portfolio is the one where the largest number of gurus have at least one share.
Max7777
ReplyMax7777 - 4 years ago
Can you expend on how this portfolio was made, how you picked the number of shares and also what is the difference between broadest portfolio and consensus portfolio. (In my mind, the most broadly held 25 stocks should also be the ones with biggest consensus, but I must be wrong)

Since this portfolio did the best, is there any prior data to see how it performed in other years and how it did in up markets vs down markets.
Bmachtig
ReplyBmachtig - 4 years ago
how has this list done for 2008? 2007? 2006? YTD2009?


GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to $400 per referral. ( Learn More)
Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names
Free 7-day Trial
FEEDBACK