The 3 Worst-Performing Dividend Achievers This Year

Target, The Andersons and SJW Group are down since the beginning of the year

Author's Avatar
Mar 15, 2017
Article's Main Image

(Published by Bob Ciura on March 14)

Dividend growth investing is one of the best ways to build wealth over the long term.

But sometimes, stocks go down.

This is the tradeoff to investing in the stock market. An investor needs to resist the urge to sell, even during market downturns.

To be fair, this is no easy task. It is very difficult to stay with stocks when we see our brokerage statements painted with red ink.

That said, those who have the steely resolve to stay in the market can reap huge rewards.

The following three stocks are all Dividend Achievers, a group of 271 stocks with at least 10 years of consecutive dividend increases.

You can see the full Dividend Achievers List here.

In addition, these three stocks are among the worst-performing Dividend Achievers year to date, suggesting their declining share prices could represent an attractive buying opportunity.

Target Corp.(TGT, Financial)

Performance: Down 24%

Target is a discount retail giant with 1,800 stores throughout the U.S.

02May2017130815.png?resize=710%2C381

Source: 4Q Earnings Presentation, page 74

Not only is Target a Dividend Achiever, it is a member of the Dividend Aristocrats as well.

Dividend Aristocrats are a group of 51 companies in the S&P 500 with at least 25 years of consecutive dividend increases.

You can see the full Dividend Aristocrats List here.

Target has fallen on hard times in 2017 because of its announcement that it will compete more aggressively on price, ramp up its e-commerce platform and invest more in its stores going forward.

This will have an adverse impact on Target’s bottom line—the company expects adjusted earnings per share to decline 20%, at the midpoint of its fiscal 2017 forecast.

While investors are rushing for the exits, long-term investors should view the announcement as a positive.

Competing on price and bolstering its online presence will be critical for Target to keep up in the new age of retail.

Internet-based retailers like Amazon.com (AMZN, Financial) are a huge threat to brick-and-mortar retailers like Target. As a result, Target is doing what needs to be done in order to compete.

Target’s e-commerce platform is performing well—digital channel sales doubled in the past three years.

This is especially evident on major shopping days like Black Friday. Target’s Black Friday sales growth has doubled in the past three years.

02May2017130816.png?resize=710%2C312

Source: 4Q Earnings Presentation, page 13

Target will also improve how it caters to changing consumer preferences.

Consumers heavily value convenience nowadays. As a result, Target hopes to become an essentials based retailer.

It has developed small stores called CityTarget and TargetExpress to be closer to big-city dwellers. By 2019, Target expects to have more than 100 of these stores in operation nationwide.

Target’s big drop this year has set up a compelling value opportunity. The stock now trades for a price-earnings (P/E) ratio of 11.

Additionally, its falling share price has lifted its dividend yield to a hefty 4.4%.

Target has raised its dividend for 45 years in a row.

Roughly three-quarters of all Americans are located 10 miles or less from a Target store. Its massive footprint should help the company more easily leverage its online capabilities.

It has demonstrated the ability to survive difficult times in the past, and will likely do so this time around.

The Andersons Inc. (ANDE, Financial)

Performance: Down 13%

The Andersons is a diversified company operating in the agriculture industry.

It operates in four core segments:

  • Rail
  • Ethanol
  • Grain
  • Plant Nutrients

The company’s overall performance is mixed as it is seeing challenges across multiple business lines. In 2016, its adjusted EPS declined 72% to 41 cents.

One specific area of weakness was the grain segment, which posted a pre-tax loss of $15.6 million, up from a $9.4 million loss the previous year.

This segment benefited from a stronger harvest season, but this was more than offset by losses incurred from closing a cob processing facility.

Helping to offset these declines is the company’s plant nutrient segment, which generated pre-tax profit of $14.2 million, compared with $121,000 the year before.

02May2017130817.png?resize=710%2C412

Source: 4Q Earnings Presentation, page 20

This was the only segment to increase pre-tax profit for the year.

Earnings declined 36% in the company’s rail segment.

Until this year, the company also held a large retail segment, with 1,000 locations across the U.S.

But The Andersons decided to exit the retail business entirely because it was not profitable. For example, The Andersons’ retail business lost $8.8 million in 2016.

02May2017130818.png?resize=710%2C437

Source: 4Q Earnings Presentation, page 11

The retail unit’s performance has deteriorated for several consecutive years, which justifies the exit.

Investors have sold the stock lower this year, most likely due to disappointment with the company’s 2016 performance.

Moving forward, management is focused on cutting costs and has identified $10 million in potential cost savings.

In addition, the company has seen some improvement in fertilizer pricing to start 2017, which could help boost the agriculture industry this year.

The company has made 82 consecutive quarterly dividends ever since the company’s listing on the Nasdaq in 1996.

The company has raised its dividend payout for 15 years in a row, including a 3.2% hike in January 2017. The stock has a 1.7% current dividend yield.

SJW Group (SJW, Financial)

Performance: Down 16%

SJW is a water utility. It is a holding company with four subsidiaries:

  • San Jose Water Co.
  • SJW Land Co.
  • SJWTX Inc.
  • Texas Water Alliance Ltd.

San Jose Water is a water utility, with both regulated and non-regulated operations.

It was originally incorporated in 1866.

02May2017130819.png?resize=710%2C470

Source: 4Q Earnings Presentation, page 7

Today, it provides water services to approximately one million people.

SJW Land owns commercial buildings and undeveloped real estate. SJWTX Inc. is also a water utility and Texas Water Alliance. is developing a water supply project in Texas.

SJW has a long track record of generating consistent growth. For example, from 2011 to 2015, the company grew EPS by 11% per year.

The major reason for this stability is because of its business model. Providing water, a necessity for sustaining human life, is just about the most stable business one can find.

The company’s stability is complemented by the fact that the vast majority—approximately 96% of revenue—from the two water utilities is regulated.

This means the company can pass along modest rate increases each year, which helps ensure a steady revenue growth rate.

02May2017130820.png?resize=710%2C494

Source: 4Q Earnings Presentation, page 12

From 2010 to 2015, SJW’s rate base grew by 8% per year on average.

But the company also routinely increases its dividend at a fairly high rate. For example, SJW raised its 2017 first-quarter dividend by 7.4%.

SJW has raised its dividend for 48 years in a row, making it a Dividend Aristocrat. With two more years of dividend increases, it will become a Dividend King—a group of 19 stocks with 50-plus years of consecutive dividend increases.

You can see the entire list of Dividend Kings here.

SJW currently pays an annualized dividend of 87 cents per share. Based on its recent share price, the stock has a 1.8% dividend yield.

Disclosure: I am long TGT.

Start a free 7-day trial of Premium Membership to GuruFocus.