GuruFocus Premium Membership

Serving Intelligent Investors since 2004. Only 96 cents a day.

Free Trial

Free 7-day Trial
All Articles and Columns »

10 Questions to Mohnish Pabrai – Update

July 06, 2007

As we reported last week, GuruFocus readers are given an opportunity by Mr. Mohnish Pabrai (also a GuruFocus reader) to ask 10 questions. We have sent the questions to him today.

There were overwhelming responses and we have received more than 100 questions. We are very proud of the quality of the questions that our readers asked. These questions show how intelligent our readers are. We looked at the questions again and again, and we want to ask all of them. However, we are limited to 10. We have made some filtering and combined some questions together. Still we have too many.

We sent these questions to Mr. Mohnish Pabrai, 17 of them, and multiple questions in each question. We give Mr. Pabrai the option of selectively answering them. If… if he answers all of them, all of us get an additional 70% gain.

Please don’t count, Mr. Pabrai!

Valuation and Investment Philosophy:

  • How does your investment philosophy differ from Warren Buffett’s and Charlie Munger’s and why? As a follower of Warren Buffett you insist in buying into companies with a "moat"; nevertheless the kind of companies you tend to invest in do not appear to have wide moats as generally described by Warren Buffett and reflected in his holdings like Coca Cola, Gillette or American Express. Could you please expand on your definition of a moat and contest it with Warren's definition?
  • Could you briefly provide some valuation techniques you use? Which method you favor or something else? I have read that if you find you are looking for excel while valuing, you take a pass. What’s your thought process when you value a company? Do you use models like a) Reproduction Costs of assets Earnings PV/Enterprise Value? b) DCF?
  • I would ask Mr. Pabrai to expand on the distinction he made in his book "The Dhando Investor" between "risk" and "uncertainty". He wrote about investing in "low-risk, high-uncertainty" situations. What are some guidelines for distinguishing whether it's risk or merely uncertainty that has depressed a stock's price?
  • What are the characteristic traits to avoid, if you want to be a successful investor? Which traits should you be looking for?
  • Can you give us your definition for special situations? Do you have a checklist with regards to "special situation" investing that you run through personally and don't mind sharing? Is Buffett's advice that we shouldn't own a stock for 10 minutes if we aren't willing to own it for 10 years relevant here?
  • What do you do with an investment which has performed unexpectedly or poorly? What information do you find most useful in this situation in deciding to sit tight, to sell or to buy more? When do you decide its time to throw in the towel before losing more of your original investment? For me, finding good companies to buy is usually not that hard; it's knowing what to do with them after you own them that's the hard part. Thanks for your advice - you are my favorite guru!
  • What has been your biggest investment mistake? Not just a stock that did not perform as expected but a process or method error? (Loved Dhandho Investor!)
  • Buffett invested in three distinct categories- Generals, Workouts, and Controls. I know you tend to avoid the latter, but relating to Generals and Workouts- how do you feel those types of investments apply to today's market? Grahamian Bargains, which can see huge returns with small amounts of capital, seem to be scarce, and M&A is so heavily covered that "workouts" now may be different than in Buffett's era.

    Do you have any particular comments on investing in "Generals" and "Workouts" as they apply to investing today?
  • Would you say that in your experience, your best investments have been derived from some obscure "hidden" asset value you find in an investment or from some traditional valuation measures?
  • Warren Buffet stated that his ideal holding period is 'forever,' and that 20 investments in a lifetime are more than enough for any individual investor. Do you agree with these statements, or should one be more flexible in their investing strategy?

Sector, Industries:

  • What exactly are your reasons for avoiding the P&C business? There are some very well run companies in this arena and Buffett has profited from the business. Does it extend beyond P&C to all types of insurance; health, auto, reinsurance etc.?
  • In pages 24-27 of "Mosaic: Perspectives On Investing", you come right out and say, "Do Not Buy Retailers". Some of today's retailers are priced very attractively today (eg. HD and WMT). The fundamentals of these companies look great and I see them as compelling reasons to buy. However, you didn't like retailers because of the transparency of the business. To me, it seems hard to duplicate a HD or WMT, but I could be wrong. It's been 5 years since your book was written and several retailer stocks have come down in price because of apathy among other things. Then, in "The Dhandho Investor", you evaluate BBBY (albeit not worth buying at the time), which implies you at least consider some retailers. My question is, "Do you still have the same conviction today to say, 'Do Not Buy Retailers' or has your opinion changed? Will you ever buy a retailer?"

Portfolio:

  • Do you maintain statistics such as the beta of your portfolio, Sharpe and Treynor ratios, etc., that you may be able to provide to readers?

Fund Size:

  • Currently you are handling less than 1 Billion dollars, as every fund manager knows size becomes an anchor to performance, as your fund increases in size, how will your approach change in stock selection? Will you move to larger companies like Buffett or will you "diversify"? Moving away from a concentrated portfolio? Is there a range of market cap stocks that you feel most comfortable with? Is there a point at which you will close your fund to new money, given the inverse correlation between size and performance?

Management:

  • Do you speak to management to judge their quality, or do you use just their performance numbers? If you speak to them, what do you ask, and if you just use the numbers, which ones do you find most important?

The Art of Selling:

  • (After reading "The Dhandho Investor" I have a few general questions) What suggestions (or more examples) can you give GuruFocus readers on the art of selling, which I consider a very difficult part of investing for a value investor.

Others:


If your questions are not included, we feel really sorry. It does not mean that they are not good questions, there were just too many. We will try to get such opportunities again later and hopefully we can ask more.

Mr. Pabrai said he can “ hopefully respond to it within a few weeks.” If we get answers to those questions, it will be one of greatest interviews in the history of value investing. We will post the answers as soon as we receive them. Stay tuned.

To our honor, Mr. Pabrai said that GuruFocus has provided “a terrific service to the community.” He himself is “fan of your site.” Evidently Mr. Pabrai lists GuruFocus as one of his favorite sources for generating investment ideas in his new book, The Dhandho Investor. Also he is one of the earliest registered users of GuruFocus, his user ID is 48, which is out of more than 20,000 registered. If you have not registered, please register today.

To take the advantages of all the features at GuruFocus, we invite you for GuruFocus Premium Membership ($249/year). Take a 7-day FREE Trial. Your margin of safety: you will not be charged if you cancel within 7 days.


Rating: 3.6/5 (27 votes)

Comments

ronca1
Ronca1 - 7 years ago
I just finished reading The Dhandho Investor? I would have liked to ask Mohnish Pabrai what are the back of the paper/book quick calculations you use to evaluate a companies worth?
kfh227
Kfh227 premium member - 7 years ago
I hope he reads these questions also :-) ..... Never thought I'd have a good one, but I just got back from vacation and reading a biography about our friend, WEB. Buffett often states that what he does requires on not be a genius, just that he have certain traits, such as patience and discipline. I was wondering if Mr Pabrai could give a few words that describes the characteristics one should try to strive for as a value investor in order to be successful at value investing. Something we one could tack to an office wall in order to keep on "in line" when investing.

I hope this works out and I hope this is just a sign of things to come for the site.

And of course, a big Thank You to Mr Pabrai!
TDDLHD
TDDLHD - 7 years ago
Mr. Pabrai currently has a large stake in Harvest Energy with the majority of its assets located in Venezuela. Why are you investing in such a risky venture when Hugo Chavez has a nasty habit of confiscating resources and nationalizing foreign and domestic companies in Venezuela?
JJINVEST
JJINVEST premium member - 7 years ago
For the question on HNR, you can find the anwers from www.valueinvestorsclub.com and the discussion board at www.fool.com . I believe that the bottomline in investing in HNR is precisely it is a low-risk but high-uncertainty investment. In other words, there is very little downside to HNR (the oil reserves are proven and profitable, Chavez has been known to get a share of the profit but never eliminate these companies, etc.) but wall street hates uncertainty (even though it is just a matter of time before HNR signs the contract with Venezuela government). Anyway, that's why HNR has jumped 25% since 1-2 months ago because some of the uncertainty was taken out (not all, but some). The rest of the upside lies in when the consistent earning kicks in in a year or two, and stock will be appreciated by more of the Wallstreet.

Please leave your comment:


Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names | Earn affiliate commissions by embedding GuruFocus Charts
GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to $400 per referral. ( Learn More)
Free 7-day Trial
FEEDBACK
Email Hide