1. How to use GuruFocus - Tutorials
  2. What Is in the GuruFocus Premium Membership?
  3. A DIY Guide on How to Invest Using Guru Strategies
Adib Motiwala
Adib Motiwala
Articles  | Author's Website |

Using a checklist to AVOID companies - Tenet Healthcare Corporation

July 06, 2010 | About:
Topic : In this article, I will present you an example of a company I avoided with my checklist.

Any good investor will tell you to have a checklist of things to look for in companies before you invest. Checklists are a good idea and can help prevent some basic mistakes and oversight on our part. Checklists also help to enforce a discipline in your investing process.

I use my checklist for two purposes.

1) Which companies are worth considering an investment.

2) Which companies are NOT worth investing in ?

My negative checklist reads:

1) Avoid companies that are highly leveraged

2) Avoid companies that do not generate FCF consistently

3) Avoid companies that have high fixed capex requirements ( especially if their FCF is weak)

4) Avoid companies where interest coverage is low.

5) Avoid companies that have poor Altman Z score that predicts likely bankruptcy.

Now, lets take a look at Tenet Healthcare Corp (NYSE:THC).

"Tenet Healthcare Corporation, an investor-owned health care services company, operates general hospitals and related health care facilities. As of December 31, 2008, Tenet Healthcare Corporation operated 49 general

hospitals; and a critical access hospital with a combined total of 14,352 licensed beds serving urban and rural communities."

Tenet Healthcare has a market Cap $2.12 billion with an enterprise value : $5.69 billion.

Value investors often start by looking at the balance sheet. I look at the March 31, 2010 statement.

Cash And Cash Equivalents $589 million

Long Term Debt $4,271 million

Total stockholder equity $739 million.

The first thing that strikes out is that there is $4.2 Billion in long term debt v/s cash of about $600 million.

1) Debt / Shareholder Equity : 4271 / 739 = 5.8 ( Graham said to avoid companies that owe more than twice of what they own. So, If Debt / Equity > 2, avoid the company.

Avoid companies that are highly leveraged : Check

I could stop looking at THC right here but lets run down the list to see what else we find

2) In 2009, THC has Operating cash flows (OCF) of $425 million. However, Capital expenditures were $456 million. Now, I do not want to get into maintenance capex versus growth capex here. For me, Free Cash Flow (FCF) = OCF - Capex = -31 million.

Avoid companies that do not generate FCF consistently: Check

3) Look at the Capex over the last 3 years and you will see high consistent capex. Even though capex has been coming down from $743 million in 2007 to $456 million in 2009, it shows me that capex requirements are quite high in this company and industry in general.

Avoid companies that have high fixed capex requirements: Check

4) Next I look at the 2009 annual income statement and find EBIT = $650 million. On the next line I find interest expense = $445 million. Wow. You do not need a calculator to know that interest coverage is quite low. Interest coverage is defined as EBIT / interest expense. = 1.46. This means that interest payments could be at risk if operating income dropped and also the fact that there is not much for error here. Finally, not a lot remains for the shareholders after paying this interest expense.

You can also do simple math to find out the interest rate. We saw that LT Debt was $4271 million and THC paid $445 million in interest expenses. My rough calculation is that interest rate on the debt is just a shade under 10%.

Avoid companies where interest coverage is low : Check

5) Altman Z score The Z-score formula may be used to predict the probability that a firm will go into bankruptcy within two years. Here you can find a free spreadsheet to compute the Z score. A score less than 1.8 means that the company is in the distress zone. THC's Z score came out to 1.35.

Avoid companies that have poor Altman Z score : Check

At this point, I have not even gone into the details of the business, its history of profitability ( or lack there of), its management and its competitors.

The checklist has helped me decide that this company is NOT one I would like to invest in.

Other investors may think of THC as a potential turnaround candidate or an asset play or a LBO candidate. I do not have the expertise to value the assets of this company or speculate about a potential LBO.

Hope you found this exercise worthwhile. If you take anything away from this article and checklist, take the first point. Avoid companies where D/E is more than 2.


Adib Motiwala

About the author:

Adib Motiwala
Adib Motiwala is a Portfolio Manager at Motiwala Capital LLC, an investment management firm that manages separate accounts for its clients.

Visit Adib Motiwala's Website

Rating: 4.7/5 (12 votes)


Please leave your comment:

GuruFocus has detected 5 Warning Signs with Tenet Healthcare Corp $THC.
More than 500,000 people have already joined GuruFocus to track the stocks they follow and exchange investment ideas.

Performances of the stocks mentioned by Adib Motiwala

User Generated Screeners

mpacholskaFrance strong 6+
FAROSFaros criteria 1
Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names | Earn affiliate commissions by embedding GuruFocus Charts
GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to $400 per referral. ( Learn More)

GF Chat