1. How to use GuruFocus - Tutorials
  2. What Is in the GuruFocus Premium Membership?
  3. A DIY Guide on How to Invest Using Guru Strategies
Sydnee Gatewood
Sydnee Gatewood
Articles (3340) 

Keeley Mid Cap Dividend Value Fund's 4th-Quarter Commentary

Discussion of markets and holdings

To Our Shareholders,

For the quarter ended December 31, 2020, the Keeley Mid Cap Dividend Value Fund's net asset value ("NAV") per Class A share rose 21.39% compared with a 20.43% gain for the Russell Mid Cap Value Index. For the full year, the Fund fell -1.77% compared with a 4.96% gain for the benchmark.


After mid caps turned in one of their worst quarterly performances since the creation of the Russell MidCap Index in the first quarter, they have generated three straight quarters of gains. In fact, two of those quarters (the second and fourth) were amongst the best in the Index's history. Also, noteworthy about the fourth quarter, was the disparity in returns between market cap sectors. Small caps, whether you looked at core, value, or growth benchmarks, outperformed large caps by 19 to 20 percentage points. Mid caps posted a narrower, but still, meaningful advantage over large-caps of 6% to 9%. Despite the rebound in relative performance, mid caps still ended up trailing large caps for the year. Because the relative performance was not as strong as for small caps, the MidCap Index ended up behind small caps as well; 17.1% for the Russell MidCap Index, vs. 20.0% for the Russell 2000 and 22.4% for the Russell Top 200. Mid caps were likely held back by their higher allocations to the lagging Real Estate and Utilities sectors.

While Value stocks outperformed in the fourth quarter, Growth stocks built a sizable lead in the rst three quarters and remained well ahead for the year; +2.9% for the Russell 3000 Value vs. +38.3% for the Russell 3000 Growth. Returns for Value have only exceeded those for Growth in three of the last ten years and the di erence in annualized returns has been 3.3% per year. We call attention to 1990s when Growth outperformed Value in six of the ten years with an average return di erential of 4.4%. e '90s were, of course, followed by the 2000s, when Value outperformed in eight of 10 years by an average of 6.7%.

It appears that we are in the early stages of a shift in market leadership from large to small and from growth to value. is new cycle is being powered by the combination of the lagged impact of global massive monetary and scal stimulus along with the prospect of multiple vaccines. We could expect strong economic growth next year accompanied by an impressive recovery in corporate earnings. Given the positive backdrop, equities are positioned for sustained gains over the next few years. Our outlook for 2021 centers on the combination of historic excess liquidity, engineered by the U.S. Federal Reserve and global central banks, coupled with a synchronized global recovery. Along with a high consumer savings rate, the U.S. housing market remains robust as evidenced by record sales of both existing and new homes. Another engine of global growth is China, which is enjoying a prolonged v-shaped rebound throughout its economy. China's industrial production rose 7% in November, while retail sales grew 5%.

Since the lows in March, the market has regained its old highs. While valuations have been somewhat stretched, our value universe of smaller company stocks still o ers reasonable risk /reward. Since the initial snapback, the market grinded higher on improving economic data and progress in managing the pandemic. In the fourth quarter, we got a big dose of both of these developments as several vaccines in clinical trials passed key hurdles, including FDA approval, and Congress passed another round of stimulus payments.

In addition, the outcome of the national election with Joe Biden as President and Democrats in control of Congress, should lead to signi cant scal stimulus and infrastructure spending, generally bene ting cyclicals, industrials, nancials and materials companies, where we deploy much of our research e ort to uncover attractively priced equities. is should also have direct impacts on consumer and construction companies. On the negative side, President-elect Biden campaigned on a platform that included raising corporate taxes. We note that in the aftermath of President Trump's election win in 2016, Financial and Energy stocks performed very well because investors believed that a Trump administration would ease regulation on those industries. However, the pandemic changed all that with those stocks among the worst performing sectors since then. We remain optimistic about prospects for the equity markets.

We believe the trajectory of the COVID-19 pandemic will continue to unnerve markets, particularly in the early part of the year. e market seems to be pricing in a relatively smooth roll-out of vaccine programs and a tapering o of the pandemic as we work through the rst half of the year. If this schedule is thrown o by signi cant delays in manufacturing or distribution, unwillingness of healthy people to be vaccinated, or mutations of the virus that make the vaccine less e ective, we think markets would struggle. Our expectation: we think that there will be some slight delays and shut-downs could get worse in the near-term, but our expectations are for conditions to be "mostly normal" by end of the year.

As for inflation, with the exception of energy, commodity prices are higher over the last year despite the economic contraction. Gold is up 24%, silver is up 47%, copper is up 26%, but also corn is up 25% and soybeans are up 37%. In ation can create cost issues for some companies, but more importantly, inflation expectations influence long-term interest rates and those impact valuations. We would expect in ation to ultimately meet the Fed's target goal of 2 percent as evidenced by the steepening yield curve. The trajectory of corporate earnings will likely influence the markets this year. Current estimates call for earnings in the Russell Top 200 to fall 10% in 2020 and then rise 18% in 2021. For small caps, we witnessed a fall of 50% last year and in 2021 expect a steep increase of greater than 100 %. Mid caps land in between at down 29% in 2020 and up 42% in 2021. While estimates for the year are often high at the beginning of the year, this is not usually the case in recovery periods. Furthermore, forward expectations have been rising over the last several months. Our expectation: We think earnings will surprise to the upside. As bottom up, fundamental value investors, we seek to uncover high quality undervalued stocks that we believe offer the best risk/reward trade-off at any given time.

Portfolio Results

The Fund outperformed its benchmark in the fourth quarter despite a drag from the Fund's small cash position and the underperformance of dividend-paying stocks relative to non-dividend-payers. We estimate that non-dividend-paying stocks within the Russell MidCap Value Index gained 28%, while dividend-paying stocks only produced a 17% total return. is is a very wide margin, although it is perhaps not too surprising given the strength in the market. e dividend-payers which lagged in previous quarters should enter a signi cant catch-up period.

In disaggregating performance into Sector Allocation and Stock Selection, the latter contributed to performance while the former detracted slightly. e most notable impact in Sector Allocation was the Fund's small cash holding; 2% on average. A small overweight in the Financial sector helped performance, while a small overweight in the Utilities sector and a small underweight in the Technology sector hurt performance a little.

The positive impact from Stock Selection was most notable in the Financials, Industrials, and Utilities sectors, while the Fund's holdings in Materials lagged the benchmark.

  • The Fund's heavy emphasis on lenders within the Financial sector helped performance as it had four stocks (Discover, South State, Popular, and Synovus) appreciate more than 50% in the quarter. Overall, all 14 of the Fund's Financial holdings appreciated during the quarter and nine of the 14 signi cantly outperformed the 29% gain in the sector within the benchmark (second best, behind only Energy). e third-quarter earnings season was very good for Financial stocks as most companies reported earnings that handily beat expectations. In addition, as vaccine companies reported successful clinical trial results, investors have become more con dent that the softness in the economy will not linger or get much worse. is lowers the risk that we see a 2008/2009-type of meltdown in credit performance.
  • Outperformance in the Industrials sector was also broad-based with nine of 10 stocks appreciating and seven of 10 outperforming. e strongest gains came in recovery-driven stocks like Air Lease (covered later in this report) and GrafTech (steel-making supplies), but more stable companies like Quanta Services (construction) chipped in as well.
  • While a slight overweight in the Utilities sector hurt overall Fund performance, the Fund's holdings within the sector outperformed those of the benchmark by a healthy margin. Most noteworthy among these were NRG Energy and MDU Resources. NRG is entirely unregulated, while MDU has signi cant unregulated assets. In a period of strong market gains, these non-regulated businesses o er more upside.
  • The only sector that signi cantly detracted from Fund performance was the Materials sector. e sector was one of the stronger sectors of the market in the fourth quarter (+25%) and the Fund's holdings did not quite keep up. e more than 100% gain in Olin's stock helped, but the decline in gold royalty company Franco-Nevada and single-digit gains in a handful of other stocks accounted for the underperformance. e Fund holds businesses that we believe are more stable than average for the sector and held up better in the rst quarter's downturn.

During the quarter, the Fund added five new positions.

Let's Talk Stocks

The top three contributors in the quarter were:

Discover Financial Services (NYSE:DFS) (DFS - $90.53 - NYSE) is one of the largest issuers of credit cards in the United States. In addition, it offers checking and saving products through its online bank and issues student and personal loans. Discover's shares appreciated sharply during the quarter as investors gained confidence that consumer credit would not deteriorate further due to COVID-19-related job losses. The large amount of government stimulus to date has helped shore up consumer balance sheets and the prospect that conditions will return to normal some time in 2021 as vaccines become widely available boosted expectations.

Marriott Vacations Worldwide (NYSE:VAC) (VAC - $137.22 - NYSE) is one of the largest developers, marketers, and managers of timeshare resorts in the world. Shares have rebounded since the first quarter's steep drop and this continued in the fourth quarter as the company continued to demonstrate the resilience in its business model. Despite the steep drop in travel and subsequent drop in new unit sales and the attendant losses, Marriott has maintained neutral/positive cash flow and its balance sheet has not been damaged like many other travel companies. In the third quarter, occupancy returned and sales began to pick up. Throughout this difficult period, Marriott has not seen a substantial rise in defaults on its timeshare loans. With vaccines now approved and being distributed, investors are becoming more confident in a 2021 rebound.

Air Lease Corporation (NYSE:AL) (AL - $44.42 – NYSE) is a leading lessor of commercial aircraft to airlines around the world. While COVID-19-related travel restrictions and related lower leisure and business travel demand have made life very difficult for Air Lease's customers, the company has been partially insulated from the challenges they face. Its fleet of newer, modern aircraft remain desirable so airlines have continued to keep them in service and pay their leases. This is not to say that customer financial restructurings and delayed deliveries of new aircraft from Boeing and Airbus have not created challenges, only that the company has done a good job of managing these headwinds. Like the other top performers in the portfolio, Air Lease shares benefitted in the fourth quarter from a solid third quarter earnings report and an improving outlook for a 2021 recovery driven by the success of coronavirus vaccines in clinical trials.

The three largest detractors in the quarter were:

KB Home (NYSE:KBH) (KBH - $33.52 – NYSE) is one of the nation's leading homebuilders and the industry has seen a strong rebound in activity that resulted from the pandemic-related issues. This set high expectations for KB Home heading into the quarter. It beat consensus estimates, raised prices to help offset expected cost inflation, and reported a solid gain in backlog. Forward guidance, however was weaker than expected partly due to strong demand putting pressure on community counts and lingering issues with the pandemic elongating the normal build cycle. The medium-term outlook for homebuilders remains favorable supported by record low mortgage rates.

Franco-Nevada Corporation (NYSE:FNV) (FNV - $125.33 – NYSE) is a leading gold-focused royalty company. The stock struggled this quarter despite posting record quarterly results as sentiment waned. Franco-Nevada trades in sympathy with gold prices and those prices stalled in the quarter as the stock market overall was strong. The underlying economics of Franco-Nevada remain attractive with solid organic growth projects now operational and the addition of high-quality oil and gas royalties. Additionally, the company is well positioned with a debt-free balance sheet and plenty of liquidity for potential accretive M&A activity.

Cabot Oil & Gas (NYSE:COG) (COG - $16.28 – NYSE) is the lowest-cost producer of natural gas in the Marcellus shale basin in the Eastern United States. The company lowered its preliminary 2021 production target on its third-quarter earnings conference call. Management has elected to stay in maintenance mode with regard to spending on drilling until fundamentals for natural gas improve. This should happen sometime in 2021 as COVID-related lockdowns ease and demand returns.


In conclusion, thank you for your investment in the KEELEY Mid Cap Dividend Value Fund. We will continue to work hard to justify your confidence and trust.

This summary represents the views of the portfolio managers as of 12/31/20. Those views may change, and the Fund disclaims any obligation to advise investors of such changes. For the purpose of determining the Fund's holdings, securities of the same issuer are aggregated to determine the weight in the Fund. Portfolio holdings are subject to change without notice and are not intended as recommendations of individual securities.

About the author:

Sydnee Gatewood
I am the editorial director at GuruFocus. I have a BA in journalism and a MA in mass communications from Texas Tech University. I have lived in Texas most of my life, but also have roots in New Mexico and Colorado. Follow me on Twitter! @gurusydneerg

Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes)


Please leave your comment:

Performances of the stocks mentioned by Sydnee Gatewood

User Generated Screeners

wigbertHigh FCF-M2
kosalmmuseBest one1
DBrizanall 2019Feb26
kosalmmuseBest one
DBrizanall 2019Feb25
MsDale*52-Week Low
Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names | Earn affiliate commissions by embedding GuruFocus Charts
GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to $400 per referral. ( Learn More)