1. How to use GuruFocus - Tutorials
  2. What Is in the GuruFocus Premium Membership?
  3. A DIY Guide on How to Invest Using Guru Strategies
Jacob Wolinsky
Jacob Wolinsky
Articles  | Author's Website |

Warren Buffett Dares Rupert Murdoch: Let's Both Release Our Tax Returns

October 05, 2011 | About:
Berkshire Hathaway's Warren Buffett sat down with longtime friend and Fortune senior editor-at-large Carol Loomis for a wide-ranging discussion about everything from George Bush to Rupert Murdoch. Below is an unedited transcript.

Here is how it it went down.

CAROL LOOMIS: Well, one of the centers of criticism has been the Wall Street Journal's editorial page.

WARREN BUFFETT: Oh, really? (Laughter.)

CAROL LOOMIS: And they've asked you to give them your income tax statement.


CAROL LOOMIS: What do you think about that?

WARREN BUFFETT: Well, I think it might be a terrific idea if they would just ask their boss, Rupert Murdoch, and he and I will meet at Fortune and we'll both give you our tax returns, and you can publish them. (Applause.)

CAROL LOOMIS: We like it. We like it. (Laughter.)

The rest of the transcript is below:

LLOYD BLANKFEIN: Now, I have the privilege of introducing Warren Buffett, who will be interviewed by Carol Loomis, Fortune's senior editor at large.

Now, what can I say about Warren that hasn't already been said? We all know about his uncanny timing, his brilliant sayings, his investing discipline, and his uncommonly common logic.

To his disciples, he's a rock star. Just head out to Omaha for his annual meeting to see for yourself, or hang our dinner table and watch all the pictures go off on all these cell phones.

To policy makers, he's a source of wise counsel. They even like to name policy proposals after him.

To CEOs, he's either salvation, a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity, the most patient investor in the world, or all three. To me, he's been a friend, a supporter, and a constant reminder of the value of not buying into the prevailing sentiment, no matter how positive or negative it gets.

Warren has principles, and they aren't hard to figure out. The difference is he always lives by them. I know the Buffett Rule is being talked and written about a lot these days, but I like to think there already was a Buffett Rule. It says: Stick to what you're good at, keep a lot of cash on hand, and answer the phone when it rings. (Laughter.) Warren, keep taking my calls.

Please join me in welcoming Warren Buffett and his good friend, Carol Loomis, to the stage. (Applause.)

CAROL LOOMIS: Good morning. Warren, here we are for a fourth year in a row. The first year was financial panic, the next year seemed to be apparent recovery. The third year was political upheaval, and now we're in the state of uncertainty about the economy and really worrying about jobs.

Now, Berkshire Hathaway (NYSE:BRK.A)(NYSE:BRK.B) as a conglomerate is such a mirror of the economy. Let me ask about it first. You've got railroads, utilities, insurance, jewelry retailers, See's Candy, Dairy Queen, Business Wire, and then a whole slew of companies that are tied in one way or another to housing, Shaw Carpet, Acme Brick, Benjamin Moore Paints, Johns Manville, Clayton.

When you survey how these businesses are doing, what does the picture say to you about the economy?

WARREN BUFFETT: As of today, our housing-related businesses are as bad as they've ever been during this period. Everything else you name is up. And our railroad carried 200,000 car loads last week, that's the highest total in three years. That's stuff moving around the country, supplying merchants and doing all kinds of things.

If you take our five largest businesses, all of them will either set records for earnings or just about set records for earnings this year. And in our retailing operations, we're seeing same-store gains just like before.

I really thought in August and September with all the turmoil in the markets, you'd see a falloff particularly in higher-priced items, but it hasn't happened yet. Maybe it will, but as of today, the recovery is still underway.

CAROL LOOMIS: Well, you've also, in addition to watching those developments, you've been wearing your newsmaker hat in more than one way.

WARREN BUFFETT: You've noticed? (Laughter.) It's a boyhood dream, I wanted to have a tax named after me. (Laughter.)

CAROL LOOMIS: Well, I'll get to that one. But, also, there was a more direct company connected new development last week. You announced that Berkshire would stand ready to buy its own stock at a price of up to 10 percent above book value at any given moment. Why did you come to that decision and how does this move square with your past criticisms of moves that other companies, sometimes other companies have made to buy their own stock?

WARREN BUFFETT: Yeah, it was a terribly complicated decision involving thousands of variables. It boiled down to the fact that we will buy our stock when we think it's selling for less than it's worth, surprise. You know, I'll buy anybody else's stock when it's selling for less than it's worth, too. (Laughter.)

I've never criticized -- in fact, I've recommended companies buy their stock when it's selling below what I call "intrinsic business value." In our particular case, not true for most companies, practically all companies, but book value happens to be an understated measure of value, but one that, in a way, is a pretty good tracking device. And I use this figure of 110 percent of book as being the limit because I know that that price is demonstrably less than the businesses are worth.

If I can buy dollar bills for 90 cents, I'll buy them. I want to warn the people that are selling to me that I believe I am buying their dollar bills for 90 cents because they're our partner. So, I give them notice first. And then if they want to sell me dollar bills cheap -- any of you want to do it, I'm here. (Laughter.)


WARREN BUFFETT: And it will depend -- you always want to have ample resources for anything that comes along. So, I limited -- I put in the announcement that we wouldn't do it if it took our consolidated cash below $20 billion, but we're comfortably above that, and I also said that it would depend if we find something else even cheaper, I may be doing that too. But for the indefinite future, if we can buy our stock at something of a discount from its real value, we're going to do it.

CAROL LOOMIS: Am I right that the times when you've criticized in the past, when you could not see that they were buying an undervalued stock at all, that their motives were really different?

WARREN BUFFETT: Yeah. I've seen it done. I've been on boards, which will go unnamed, much to their gratitude, where basically they want to buy the stock, A, because it's fashionable, maybe, B, you know, because they want to tell the world they think their stock is cheap no matter what the price is. In fact, I've seen very few that have tied it to any metric when they've announced a purchase. And then sometimes they say they're buying it to cover stock options and other things like that. Well, if it makes sense to buy in the stock, you buy in the stock. It doesn't make any difference whether you're issuing stock options or not, if it doesn't, it doesn't.

Full article here: http://management.fortune.cnn.com/2011/10/04/warren-buffett-transcript/?iid=EL

About the author:

Jacob Wolinsky
My investment ideas have been inspired by many of value investors including Benjamin Graham, Charles Royce, John Neff, Joel Greenblatt, Peter Lynch, Seth Klarman,Martin Whitman and Bruce Greenwald. .I live with my wife and daughter in Monsey, NY. I can be contacted jacobwolinsky(AT)gmail.com and my blog is www.valuewalk.com

Visit Jacob Wolinsky's Website

Rating: 4.0/5 (33 votes)


Brianbook premium member - 6 years ago
Let's include the Koch brothers, & see if they reported their income from Iran business dealings.
Yswolinsky - 6 years ago    Report SPAM
Are you a paid operative of the DNC? The only comments you make are political ones.

If you want to bring up politics you can thank Obama for supporting the Iranian regime in 2009 when there was a good chance of it collapsing.
Brianbook premium member - 6 years ago
I am a big fan of the wisdom of Warren Buffett who has faith in moral capitalism as envisioned by moral philosopher Adam Smith, Lord Keynes, & most recently, Jeffrey Sachs in "The Prize of Civilization".
Yswolinsky - 6 years ago    Report SPAM
This site is meant for investing. Obviously politics come up, but this is not really the place to focus on it. There are tons of news sites where people can discuss politics, Guru Focus is not the place IMHO.

I think most readers of the site would agree with my statements.
Brianbook premium member - 6 years ago
My comments are relevant to the article which you submitted. If Guru Focus (not you) thinks otherwise, they can remove them. I will abide by their editing decision.

For what it is worth, I am a political independent.
Roark1 - 6 years ago    Report SPAM
Great (full) interview. When I initially read Buffet's comments in the press, I did not think I would agree with his views on tax policy. However, upon hearing his rationale and his supporting facts, I find his reasoning much more persuasive.

Separately, his thoughts on unemployment and the extent to which the housing/construction industry plays into our current difficulties was very enlightening.

I guess that's why they call him "The Oracle...."

Please leave your comment:

Performances of the stocks mentioned by Jacob Wolinsky

User Generated Screeners

rael2222PUNTO G2
pbarker461 Dividend, ptbv, rsi
Doug Taylor<3 pe
nec5555Pat Dorsey Moat 5Y v1
nec5555Pat Dorsey Moat 5Y
Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names | Earn affiliate commissions by embedding GuruFocus Charts
GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to $400 per referral. ( Learn More)

GF Chat