1. How to use GuruFocus - Tutorials
  2. What Is in the GuruFocus Premium Membership?
  3. A DIY Guide on How to Invest Using Guru Strategies
Dr. Paul Price
Dr. Paul Price
Articles (513)  | Author's Website |

Washington’s Biggest Lie (and Why it Continues to be Told)

December 02, 2012 | About:



Normal people have no trouble defining how they measure inflation in their own lives. They compare what the same exact purchases of goods and services cost them today versus one-year earlier. It would include everything they spend on.

Big ticket items like gasoline, insurance (health, life, auto and property/casualty), food and utility bills have the greatest impact. Increases in other major expense categories such as college tuition, property taxes, FICA, Federal, state and local income taxes can also add tremendously to your year-over-year true cost of living.

Those of us old enough to have lived through the 1970s remember the bad old days when prices were escalating at a sickening pace. The value of a dollar fell 30.9% in the five years through 1974 and plunged 91.87% cumulatively in the decade that ended January 1979.

The officially reported 1980 CPI increase of 13.91% was the "straw that broke the camel’s back" in terms of what our leaders were willing to admit to. They decided to change the way CPI was calculated to avoid making people even more upset.

Intentionally understating CPI also served to diminish COLA (cost of living adjustments) in government salaries, pensions and social security obligations. It also kept the rates paid on government borrowing somewhat below what would otherwise have been demanded by bond vigilantes. Those nasty lenders insisted on being compensated for the fast-diminishing value of their dollars.

Unions across America used the high CPI rates to justify huge increases in pay and benefits. While inflation calmed down from the roaring period described below the BLS again adjusted their calculation of CPI in 1990 to further understate the truth as most of us see it.

Today’s headline core CPI excludes food and energy completely. That’s impossible for us to do that in our real lives. Remember the old sub-$2 per gallon gasoline prices? How about the health insurance premiums, grocery expenses and electric bills you’re paying today versus four or five years ago?


CPI Year-to-Year Growth

The CPI-U (consumer price index) is the broadest measure of consumer price inflation for goods and services published by the US Government’s Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS).

While the headline number usually is the seasonally-adjusted month-to-month change, the formal CPI is reported on a not-seasonally-adjusted basis, with annual inflation measured in terms of year-to-year percent change in the price index.

The chart below shows the Shadow Government Stats -Alternate CPI estimate. It figures inflation based on our own government’s official methodology for computing the CPI-U in the years through 1980.

Under the old rules US inflation has been in the double-digits for much of the preceding five years. The "new" BLS numbers want you to believe price increases since 2008 have been quite mild.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics also uses a technique called substitution to hold down their reported inflation figures. If an item in their index goes up in price they can assume the consumer would simply trade down to something cheaper instead.

If your favorite rib-eye steak went from $7.99 to $12.99 per pound you’d simply eat hamburger instead. Have those organic bananas gotten too expensive? Try prunes. Need a replacement for your Lexus? Buy a Kia instead. Presto, there’s no inflation evident in any of those situations according to the BLS.

All these changes in the way CPI is calculated have been duly disclosed to the public. That doesn’t make them any less dishonest when viewed the way most people gauge changes in their real cost of living.



Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke has put Bond Vigilantes on the endangered species list with his multiple, and now eternal QE programs. Interest rates are no longer useful as measures of present or future inflation.

If truth in advertising were being strictly enforced the BLS might be renamed just the BS.

Please post comments to this article letting others know which view matches your personal, real-life experience.

Dr. Paul Price, Dec. 2, 2012

About the author:

Dr. Paul Price


Visit Dr. Paul Price's Website

Rating: 3.8/5 (18 votes)


BEL-AIR - 4 years ago    Report SPAM
In Canada I build houses...

A lot was $45,000 12 years ago, now it is $165,000....

The house and lot I sold for $150,000 now it is $430,000

The lot alone costs more to buy now then I sold the lot and house for..

This year alone lots went up $30,000....

6 years back used to pay $.99 for a whopper jr, now it is $2.50 plus is smaller.

Meals at restaurant at least $15 for a basic meal...

Go to pizza hit with a girl here order a few drinks with a pizza easily $50

Only thing cheaper is technology, but that always goes down with time, like pc etc.

Everything were I live is getting so expensive and out of sight and keeps going up an up ever year... It is impossible to hire someone here even for meager no skill jobs for less the $14 a hour due to boom here, so everything is expensive due to such high wages here as well as well as high rents and housing costs.

This is what happens when you print to much money, and money chases to few goods, it is like money is losing it's value each and every year by at least 6% a year.

Eventually inflation will get so high not be able to hide it, then interest rates will kick in and the entire debt ridden western house of cards will come down, as interest on the debt alone will take most of the taxes to service.

I say within the next 5 years.

Superguru - 4 years ago    Report SPAM

so what do we do - Buy gold? Buy real estate?
Mla - 4 years ago    Report SPAM
Yes, but Bel-Air, you have the double problem of a housing bubble that's still intact. Not that I'm saying there isn't real inflation in Canada -- just that you'll probably see the housing-related numbers drop significantly on a relative basis once it pops.
BEL-AIR - 4 years ago    Report SPAM
Yes you are right about the bubble, I am a builder and admit to the bubble.
JUDS1234567 - 4 years ago    Report SPAM

Welcome to the age of financial repression
Seanickson - 4 years ago    Report SPAM

shadowstats numbers are way off, anyone who lived through the 1970s could tell you that today is nothing like that. 10% yoy inflation today, thats ridiculous. Personally, I think the BLS numbers are closer to reality.
AlbertaSunwapta - 4 years ago    Report SPAM
It's not like the '70s because the expectations created by official stats aren't being built into everyone's prices and wage demands. Shadowstats calculates some or all the numbers the old way for comparability. Williams is providing a great service.

One other consideration: the basket is an after-tax basket of goods. Your wage demands have to be high enough to first compensate for income taxes to then leave enough of a gain to provide for the rising cost of living. Think about that and then think about those unions that only ask for the inflation rate an get critiqued for doing so. It gets interesting when you think through the impacts of inflation indexing of brackets vs. your highest MTR. Pity those on LTD, etc. relying on COLA adjustments.

While we're on the topic, here's Buffett's views...

How Inflation Swindles the Equity Investor

The central problem in the stock market is that the return on capital hasn´t risen with inflation. It seems to be stuck at 12 percent.

by Warren E. Buffett, FORTUNE May 1977



Sapporosteve premium member - 4 years ago
25 years ago I bought a Nissan Pulsar for $13,000 in Australia including air conditioning. Now I can buy a car for about the same money and probably even less as a proportion of my income. Air conditioning is standard, as are all the other accessories that we take for granted. Standards of living for most people is higher than it was and continue the march upward.

So when you talk about inflation, you might want to talk about productivity increases as well.

I remember the 70's too. Only the rich had nice cars, air conditioning in their homes and were university educated. In Australia, air conditioning in a home is just about standard. So are nice cars and plenty of the middle class are getting educated at university.

A near 60% increase in the price of steak. Can you cite a case where this has happened? You did not mention any time period. 12 month price increase?

I suggest if you have a Lexus, then you might not need to worry to much about inflation.

Your article is pure sensationalism.

Sapporosteve premium member - 4 years ago
Here is a recent update from John Williams - the man behind shadowstats.

“The U.S. economic and systemic-solvency crises of the last five years continue to deteriorate. Yet they remain just the precursors to the coming Great Collapse: a hyperinflationary great depression. The unfolding circumstance will encompass a complete loss in the purchasing power of the U.S. dollar; a collapse in the normal stream of U.S. commercial and economic activity; a collapse in the U.S. financial system, as we know it; and a likely realignment of the U.S. political environment.

Outside timing on the hyperinflation remains 2014, but events of the last year have accelerated the movement towards this ultimate dollar catastrophe. Following Mr. Bernanke‘s extraordinary efforts to debase the U.S. currency in late-2010, the dollar had lost its traditional safe-haven status by early-2011. Whatever global confidence had remained behind the U.S dollar was lost in July and August. “

Hyperinflation by 2014!..........honestly can anyone treat this guy seriously. Track his predictions. You might be surprised how incorrect and off base he has been. Every time he is wrong, he simply pushed the dates back.

Dr. Paul Price
Dr. Paul Price - 4 years ago    Report SPAM

Those who were early in predicting the housing bust were called crackpots ... until it happened.

Being early doesn't mean being wrong, except on the timing.
Jasonfrey33 premium member - 4 years ago
Inflation is complex to calculate. Reviewing the BLS website, there are certainly shortcomings. Most notably; not including personal income tax changes or health insurance premiums. They do calculate cost of health care, but this does not account for the rapid transfer of cost from employer to employee. The shadow stats may be true to the old standard of inflation, but the numbers are not realistic to my life. I have not experienced a 70% decrease in purchase power since 2002. I would have to say the CPI is closer to my life, but understated due to factors mentioned in the article. Most notably my food costs seem to have risen higher than BLS numbers.

However, I would be very surprised if future changes are not made to the CPI to ease budget defecits. These future changes are likely to be more dramatic than past changes and will probably include the substitution component into the official CPI number. I also feel for those on fixed incomes without any investments to hedge inflation. They are dependent on the government providing an accurate CPI. Politicians depend on the CPI as an easy way out when it comes to budget debates.

Cmwy10a premium member - 4 years ago
I often wonder why the cost of the largest expense for the top 50% ( those who pay taxes) is not included. The cost of government goes up every year at an outrageous rate while the quality, like education, goes down!
SeaBud premium member - 4 years ago
It is undeniable that inflation will occur in the future - a 6th grader could tell you that. Recognizing the conditions precipitating rampant inflation is the trick. The rise in commodity prices is largely based on the creation of a huge worldwide "middle class" (china/india). This is counterbalanced by the availability of cheap products produced by these workers (electronics, appliances, cars). If you chose to pay for a toyota over an equal car from a third world country (coming, not available yet, but maybe Kia), that is an example of your purchase choice, not inflation. Substitution is a valid concept.

Debt is an issue in the west, but the US could EASILY balance the budget with just a few rational choices (increase age to SS/Medicare, raise taxes on wealthiest, reduce defense spending). It is a political, not an economic, issue. Note, the US will be a net energy exporter within a decade.

Read Fared Zakharia's book on the Rise of Others - the US is not falling but the rest of the world has been rising since WWII - which is natural and good as it will produce stable countries with more consumers. US citizens may no longer be able to expect filet mignon as our birthright. We may substitute other protein. My friends in Holland tell me that 2 families share a pleasure boat. This is substitution but does it meaningfully harm their lives? Not really.

Summary - "Substitution" is a valid economic concept, the world continues to change and focusing narrowly on certain segments is less valid than ever, and never bet against the United States. Having said that, times of irrational exuberance and fear will occur, thankfully, providing many of us opportunities to buy assets on the cheap! I love when fear is in vogue....

Please leave your comment:

Performances of the stocks mentioned by Dr. Paul Price

User Generated Screeners

ligeron.4gJoel Greenblatt
liuzishuNon-Div Beneish EV/EBITDA
liuzishuNon-Div Beneish ROA/E
alberto.lopezblancoMomentum / Deep Value_V2
alberto.lopezblancoMomentum / Deep Value_volume
alberto.lopezblancoAdquirer's Multiple
HOLKLSUTest First Group Trump Trade
pbarker46Begin here, dividend growth
Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names | Earn affiliate commissions by embedding GuruFocus Charts
GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to $400 per referral. ( Learn More)

GF Chat