Google Faces Landmark Legal Battle Over Monopolistic Practices

The outcome of this trial will have far-reaching implications on the future of innovation, data collection and AI technologies

Author's Avatar
Sep 12, 2023
Summary
  • The DOJ alleges that Google, a subsidiary of Alphabet, has established its online search monopoly through unfair competitive practices.
  • A government victory could lead to remedies such as the dissolution of Google's exclusive search deals, influencing the tech industry's trajectory.
  • Amidst the ongoing legal challenges, it is crucial to assess Alphabet's financial health and performance.
Article's Main Image

In a landmark legal battle, Google faces off against the U.S. Department of Justice over allegations of monopolistic practices in the online search landscape.

The DOJ contends that Google, a subsidiary of Alphabet Inc. (GOOG, Financial) (GOOGL, Financial), established its dominant position by creating innovative technologies and entering into exclusive contracts and agreements, which made it the default search engine on mobile devices and web browsers. This, the DOJ argues, severely hindered the ability of rivals to compete and limited the avenues available for competitors to reach consumers. Google, however, maintains that its contracts with various companies, including Apple Inc. (AAPL, Financial), Samsung Electronics (SSNLF, Financial), Firefox and Verizon (VZ, Financial), are not exclusive and have not prevented people from using other search engines. The company contends that its product provides a superior experience, hence its widespread adoption by consumers.

The outcome of this trial will not only impact Google and its parent company, but will also have far-reaching implications on the future of innovation, data collection and the development of artificial intelligence technologies.

A win for the government is unlikely to lead to a split or divestment, but it could result in measures like ending Google's exclusive search agreements. Such a decision would undoubtedly influence the trajectory of the tech industry and the future of online innovation.

As the legal proceedings unfold, it is crucial to assess the financial health and performance of Alphabet, the tech giant behind Google. In this discussion, we will explore Alphabet's financial statistics, dissect its position within the global interactive media industry and evaluate its overall stability amidst ongoing legal challenges. This comprehensive analysis will provide a clearer understanding of Alphabet's current standing and its potential future trajectory.

The U.S. Department of Justice vs. Google

The upcoming antitrust trial against Google, initiated by the U.S. Department of Justice, is a critical event with potential repercussions for the digital world. Google faces allegations of monopolizing online searches, a significant charge considering the tech giant's widespread influence. As the trial unfolds in a Washington district court, many anticipate its outcome will redefine internet access and usage for millions of Americans. This case, initiated in 2020, marks the government's first trial against Google despite joining another case concerning monopoly concerns in advertising. Despite some charges being dismissed by Judge Amit P. Mehta, significant allegations remain, including Google's exclusive contracts with phone manufacturers hindering competitors. The trial's outcome may also hint at potential shifts in the tech industry, as other tech giants face similar legal challenges. The case's specifics revolve around Google's handling of search advertising and its alleged efforts to stifle competition by making itself the default search engine on various devices.

While the government contends this approach made it virtually impossible for competitors to gain traction, Google maintains its agreements did not inhibit the use of other search engines and that users prefer its service. The broader implications of the case extend beyond Google, as it is part of a series of legal challenges big tech companies face, potentially signaling a changing tide in the industry.

Ultimately, the trial's outcome may not result in a breakup or divestiture of Google. Still, it could lead to the termination of its exclusive search deals, affecting innovation, data collection and artificial intelligence technologies. As the world watches the trial unfold, its impact will undoubtedly extend far beyond Google and its competitors. With the digital landscape evolving rapidly and tech giants facing increasing scrutiny, the trial's outcome could set a precedent for future legal challenges and shape the digital world for years.

Alphabet's financial position

Alphabet's financial performance has been robust despite the ongoing legal challenges. The company has a year-to-date return of 52.37%. Its three-year revenue growth rate per share stands at 22.9%, which is better than 73.26% of companies in the interactive media industry. The three-year Ebitda growth rate per share is 21.8%, ranked better than 63.33% of competitors. Additionally, the three-year free cash flow growth rate per share is 27.2%, better than 73.61% of industry peers.

However, the future three to five-year total revenue growth rate is 8.03%, which ranked worse than 52.75% of the industry. The future three to five-year earnings per share without non-recurring items growth rate is 15.76%, better than 52.38% of industry peers. Moreover, the three-year share buyback ratio is 2.3%, above 93.51% of competitors.

Alphabet's price-earnings ratio is 28.84, below 63.38% of competitors, while the forward price-earnings ratio is 20.37, worse than 57.89% of the same group.

Takeaway

Despite its ongoing legal challenges, Alphabet has demonstrated strong financial performance, ranking better than the majority of companies in the interactive media industry in several key metrics. The outcome of the legal battle with the DOJ will have significant implications for the company and the broader tech industry. However, it is essential to note that Alphabet's dominant position, network effects and continuous innovation make it a powerful player in the global digital landscape.

Disclosures

I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and have no plans to buy any new positions in the stocks mentioned within the next 72 hours. Click for the complete disclosure