ovenerio

Gabelli, Fisher and Gayner Are Betting on a Fairly Valued Stock

According to GuruFocus Guru Trades, on June 30, Mario Gabelli (Trades, Portfolio) and Ken Fisher (Trades, Portfolio) take a long position on Nike, Inc. (NYSE:NKE). The company, a \$67.12 billion market cap, has a trailing P/E ratio that indicates that the stock is fairly valued (25.9x vs 25.9x of industry mean). So one question arises: Why are these hedge fund managers betting on it?

So in this article, let's take a look at a model which is applicable to stable, mature, dividend-paying firms and try to find the intrinsic value of the stock. Although the model has a number of characteristics that make it useful and appropriate for many applications, it is by no means the be-all and end-all for valuation. The purpose is to force investors to evaluate different assumptions about growth and future prospects.

Valuation

In stock valuation models, dividend discount models (DDM) define cash flow as the dividends to be received by the shareholders. Extending the period indefinitely, the fundamental value of the stock is the present value of an infinite stream of dividends according to John Burr Williams.

Although this is theoretically correct, it requires forecasting dividends for many periods, so we can use some growth models like: Gordon (constant) growth model, the Two or Three stage growth model or the H-Model (which is a special case of a two-stage model). With the appropriate model, we can forecast dividends up to the end of the investment horizon where we no longer have confidence in the forecasts and then forecast a terminal value based on some other method, such as a multiple of book value or earnings.

To start with, the Gordon Growth Model (GGM) assumes that dividends increase at a constant rate indefinitely.

This formula condenses to: V0=(D0 (1+g))/(r-g)=D1/(r-g)

where:

V0 = fundamental value

D0 = last year dividends per share of Exxon's common stock

r = required rate of return on the common stock

g = dividend growth rate

Let´s estimate the inputs for modeling:

Required Rate of Return (r)

The capital asset pricing model (CAPM) estimates the required return on equity using the following formula: required return on stockj = risk-free rate + beta of j x equity risk premium

Assumptions:

Risk-Free Rate: Rate of return on LT Government Debt: RF = 2.67%. This is a very low rate because of today´s context. Since 1900, yields have ranged from a little less than 2% to 15%; with an average rate of 4.9%. So I think it is more appropriate to use this rate.

Beta: β =0.67

GGM equity risk premium = (1-year forecasted dividend yield on market index) + (consensus long-term earnings growth rate) – (long-term government bond yield) = 2.13% + 11.97% - 2.67% = 11.43%[1]

rNKE = RF + βNKE [GGM ERP]

= 4.9% + 0.67 [11.43%]

= 12.56%

Dividend growth rate (g)

The sustainable growth rate is the rate at which earnings and dividends can grow indefinitely assuming that the firm´s debt-to-equity ratio is unchanged, and it doesn´t issue new equity.

g = b x ROE

b = retention rate

ROE=(Net Income)/Equity= ((Net Income)/Sales).(Sales/(Total Assets)).((Total Assets)/Equity)

The “PRAT” Model:
g= ((Net Income-Dividends)/(Net Income)).((Net Income)/Sales).(Sales/(Total Assets)).((Total Assets)/Equity)

Let´s collect the information we need to get the dividend growth rate:

 Financial Data (USD \$ in millions) May. 2014 May. 2013 May. 2012 Cash dividendsdeclared 799.000 703.000 619.000 Net income applicable to common shares 2.693.000 2.472.000 2.211.000 Net sales 27.799.000 25.313.000 23.331.000 Total assets 18.594.000 17.545.000 15.465.000 Total Shareholders' equity 10.824.000 11.081.000 10.381.000 Ratios Retentionrate 0,70 0,72 0,72 Profitmargin 0,097 0,10 0,09 Assetturnover 1,50 1,44 1,51 Financialleverage 1,70 1,63 1,53 Retention rate = (Net Income – Cash dividends declared) ÷ Net Income = 0,70 Profit margin = Net Income ÷ Net sales = 0,10 Asset turnover = Net sales ÷ Total assets = 1,50 Financial leverage = Total assets ÷ Total Shareholders' equity = 1,72 Averages Retentionrate 0,71 Profitmargin 0,10 Assetturnover 1,48 Financialleverage 1,62 g = Retention rate × Profit margin × Asset turnover × Financial leverage Dividendgrowthrate 16,52%

Because, for most companies, the GGM is unrealistic, let´s consider the H-Model which assumes a growth rate that starts high and then declines linearly over the high growth stage, until it reverts to the long-run rate. A smoother transition to the mature phase growth rate that is more realistic.

Dividend growth rate (g) implied by Gordon growth model (long-run rate)

With the GGM formula and simple math:

g = (P0.r - D0)/(P0+D0)

= (\$76.73 ×12.56% – \$0.96) ÷ (\$76.73 + \$0.96) = 11.17%.

The growth rates are:

 Year Value g(t) 1 g(1) 16,52% 2 g(2) 15,18% 3 g(3) 13,84% 4 g(4) 12,50% 5 g(5) 11,17%

G(2), g(3) and g(4) are calculated using linear interpolation between g(1) and g(5).

Calculation of Intrinsic Value

 Year Value Cash Flow Presentvalue 0 Div 0 0,96 1 Div 1 1,12 0,99 2 Div 2 1,29 1,02 3 Div 3 1,47 1,03 4 Div 4 1,65 1,03 5 Div 5 1,83 1,02 5 Terminal Value 146,61 81,15 Intrinsicvalue 86,23 Current share price 76,73

Final comment

Using a margin of safety, one should buy a stock when it is worth more than its price on the market (plus a margin: I recommend 20%). We found that intrinsic value is about 12% higher than share price, so we can conclude that the stock is fairly valued and it makes sense to hold the stock if you already bought it.

We have covered just one valuation method, and investors should not rely on it alone in order to determine a fair (over/under) value for a potential investment.

Hedge fund gurus have also been active in the company. Tom Gayner has also taken long positions in the second quarter of 2014.

Disclosure: Omar Venerio holds no position in any stocks mentioned.

[1] These values were obtained from Bloomberg´s CRP function.

ovenerio
Omar Venerio is capital markets, derivatives, corporate finance and financial management professor. He is passionate about the stock market and providing independent fundamental research and hedge fund and insider trading-focused investigation.

 Currently 3.00/512345 Rating: 3.0/5 (2 votes) Voters:

 Latest Guru Picks Value Strategies Warren Buffett Portfolio Ben Graham Net-Net Real Time Picks Buffett-Munger Screener Aggregated Portfolio Undervalued Predictable ETFs, Options Low P/S Companies Insider Trends 10-Year Financials 52-Week Lows Interactive Charts Model Portfolios DCF Calculator RSS Feed Monthly Newsletters The All-In-One Screener Portfolio Tracking Tool
GuruFocus has detected 1 Warning Sign with Nike Inc \$NKE.
More than 500,000 people have already joined GuruFocus to track the stocks they follow and exchange investment ideas.

→User Generated Screeners

alexbernal0 QUALITY growth x div EPS GROWTH 1Y 5-29-17 EPS GROWTH 3Y 5-29-17 EPS GROWTH 10 Y 5-29-17 EPS GROWTH 5-29-17 EPS GROWTH 5-28-17 2 P/Es under 10 Mini Group Low Shiller P/E 5% within 52wk
Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names | Earn affiliate commissions by embedding GuruFocus Charts
GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to \$400 per referral. ( Learn More)