Chewy (CHWY, Financial) is experiencing a dip in its stock price following the unexpected resignation of CFO David Reeder. This comes alongside a reaffirmation of its Q1 2025 guidance, which has not met investor expectations after a strong Q4 earnings report in March. Reeder, who joined Chewy in March 2023 from Global Foundries, will leave to become a CEO in the semiconductor sector after the Q1 2025 results on June 11, 2025. His departure raises questions about Chewy's ability to maintain its recent financial success.
- Executive turnover is often seen as a risk to stability, especially in the competitive e-commerce market facing challenges like tariffs and inflation. The lack of a named successor for Reeder adds to these concerns, potentially unsettling the market.
- Reeder's recent sale of approximately $16 million in stock during February suggests a lack of long-term commitment, further affecting investor confidence.
- Chewy reaffirmed its Q1 guidance with projected net sales of $3.06-$3.09 billion and EPS of $0.30-$0.35. This decision, without an upward revision, likely added to negative sentiment, despite a 146% year-over-year share increase. The cautious guidance reflects potential concerns over consumer spending in discretionary pet categories.
- In Q4, Chewy saw growth driven by increased active customers and enhanced loyalty through its Autoship program. Autoship sales rose 21% to $2.62 billion, making up 80.6% of net sales. Despite solid Q1 guidance, it may appear conservative, not fully leveraging Q4's momentum.
The combination of Reeder's departure, his stock sales, and the absence of a successor has unsettled investors, casting doubt on Chewy’s ability to sustain its financial growth amid a challenging market environment. The reaffirmation of Q1 2025 guidance, despite strong Q4 results, has further disappointed investors, contributing to the decline in stock price. While operational momentum continues, leadership changes and cautious guidance present near-term risks.
- CEO Buys, CFO Buys: Stocks that are bought by their CEO/CFOs.
- Insider Cluster Buys: Stocks that multiple company officers and directors have bought.
- Double Buys: Companies that both Gurus and Insiders are buying
- Triple Buys: Companies that both Gurus and Insiders are buying, and Company is buying back.
