1. How to use GuruFocus - Tutorials
  2. What Is in the GuruFocus Premium Membership?
  3. A DIY Guide on How to Invest Using Guru Strategies
Grahamites
Grahamites
Articles (306) 

Reflections on JD.com

Lessons learned from my investment

September 11, 2018 | About:

Recently Richard Liu, the CEO of JD.com (NASDAQ:JD), appeared on major U.S. media websites recently, and not for good reasons unfortunately. The stock sold off as a reaction to the negative news. In the past, I’ve written about why I invested in JD. Today, I’ll discuss why I’m no longer an investor in JD and the lessons I learned from it.

When I first looked at JD.com, Liu was determined and more humble and knew his circle of competence. JD was very strong in consumer electronics and had a good reputation for never selling fake products. JD was targeting premium tier 1 and tier 2 cities and was in the process of building a massive moat in its logistic system and distribution centers.

The key thesis in JD’s long-term success was the national competitive advantage of China in terms of technological and infrastructure leapfrog and in terms of the persistence, diligence and resilience of the Chinese working class. JD’s typical employees work more than 60 hours a week while only getting paid a little over USD $15,000 to $16,000 per year. Liu designed the system in a way that most of the employees are like the Vietnamese Americans that Peter Kaufman hired at Glenair. I thought this extraordinary culture, coupled with China’s national competitive advantage and rising e-commerce needs, was crucial for the long-term success of JD.com.

Liu was also unconventional because with the support of Hillhouse Capital and a few other long-term investors, he had been spending billions and billions to widen JD’s moat day by day, burdening short-term financials. Naysayers criticized JD’s level of capital expenditures because they think the return on investment is at best uncertain. But as a long-term investor of JD, I was applauding the level of capex. JD’s last-mile delivery network would make Jeff Bezos jealous – if only Amazon could hire low-cost, hardworking countrymen to ride around on motorbikes for last-mile delivery, which is critical but very expensive in the U.S. even with Amazon.

It looked like JD’s business was doing well, especially in 2016 and 2017, with accelerating growth in gross merchandise value and monthly active users and growing customer satisfaction. Liu married a beautiful and intelligent woman, and the happy pictures of the family went around in China. All looked good on the surface.

At the same time, some concerning signs developed along the way.

First of all and most concerning was Liu started to show signs of having too big of an ego and Persian messenger syndrome. He started to exaggerate JD’s success and made the claim that JD would surpass Alibaba in five years. He was running a one-man show at JD and made it very hard for his senior executives to disagree with him.

Another red flag was JD’s stepping out of its circle of competence in offline efforts. JD’s offline retail effort was probably doomed for underperformance. China’s internet and e-commerce penetration rates rose rapidly. However, it is also obvious that peak penetration is not far away, and the combination of online channel and offline channel is the future.

The tech giants took different approaches in the online-offline integration. Amazon (NASDAQ:AMZN) started on its own but then bought Whole Foods Market. Alibaba (NYSE:BABA) and Tencent (TCEHY) partnered with businesses that have extensive offline retail experience such as Suning, InTime and Yonghui Supermarkets.

But JD chose to do it on its own with a super aggressive and unrealistic expansion plan. Suning, JD’s biggest competitor in the 3C (computers, communication, consumer) market, with extensive experience, is going much slower and partnered with Alibaba. My channel checks earlier this year suggested a very large amount of JD’s new retail stores are unprofitable.

China’s e-commerce is still growing at a decent rate. But in JD’s traditionally strong 3C market, both Suning and T-Mall are catching up. And in JD’s weak markets, Pinduoduo came out from nowhere and has grown its user base to more than 300 million in three years.

I also have to admit that back in early 2016, I didn’t think Alibaba had much of a chance to catch up on logistics. It looked like JD had built a wide moat and was years ahead of T-Mall and Taobao. But what happened subsequently was really impressive. Hats-off to Alibaba’s management team. Amazingly, Alibaba’s Cainiao Network has very intelligently caught up with JD. JD’s logistic moat has narrowed considerably. At the same time, JD’s cost was much higher because Liu has promised his largely rural-born employees good welfare and a salary.

Looking back, there are a few old lessons.

1. As investors, we constantly evaluate both confirming evidence and disconfirming evidence. With JD.com, both confirming evidence and disconfirming evidence were present during the time I held the shares. Obviously it was too late to overweigh the disconfirming evidence.

2. I’ve watched Liu's ego getting bigger and bigger over time. When management started to make bold and unrealistic claims, it was time to reevaluate the thesis even though the fundamentals of the business were progressing as expected.

3. Valuation matters, but when the management team and the competitive environment changes, it’s time to remember the adage, “Not everything that counts can be counted, and not everything that counted truly counts.” In terms of multiples, JD’s appearing very cheap now. But as the moat has narrowed considerably, JD’s probably more expensive now than it was two years ago when the multiple was higher.

Disclosure: Long Alibaba and Tencent.

About the author:

Grahamites
A global value investor constantly seeking to acquire worldly wisdom. My investment philosophy has been inspired by Warren Buffett, Charlie Munger, Howard Marks, Chuck Akre, Li Lu, Zhang Lei and Peter Lynch.

Rating: 4.3/5 (16 votes)

Voters:

Comments

dlee
Dlee - 2 months ago    Report SPAM

Always funny to read that a falling stockprice affects people's opinion about a company.

It's better to stop picking stocks manually when your buy/sell decisions are based on emotions.

Grahamites
Grahamites premium member - 2 months ago

Dlee - thanks for commenting. The fundamentals of the business changed and management changed, which I've laid out in the article. That's why my opinion on the company changed.

vargsmane
Vargsmane - 2 months ago    Report SPAM

It's pretty apparent that the author is just salty about the drop in stockprice. The main critic is that Lius ego is getting too big and complaining that online retail doesn't have a moat - which it never had. The fundamentals are still extremely attractive and I don't care for what Liu does in his free time as long as the company runs. Accelerating revenue growth, margin expansion, increasing ROE and ROIC, PS of under 0.7 and rising cash flow. Also the endorsement by Google and Tencent. I'm not long yet but will buy as soon as the price is at an even cheaper level. This is a conviction buy.

The Science of Hitting
The Science of Hitting - 2 months ago    Report SPAM

Good article Grahamites. I commend you for your openness and honesty.

tim1248
Tim1248 - 2 months ago    Report SPAM

I was at a conference last year end where the CFO of JD had a 50 minutes presentation. He spent 40 minutes bitching about being bullied by Alibaba. That to me is a sign of trouble.

Slava Vershkov
Slava Vershkov - 2 months ago    Report SPAM

Grahamites, I found great value in your article and everyone should. As Charlie repeats through his whole career: 'Invert, always invert' and 'Tell me where I'm going to die so I'll never go there'. It is as important to know why businesses fail and where mistakes are coming from as to learn nice beautiful success stories. Really, really valuable insights!

Regarding CEOs and their free time, I would not wish to be a co-owner of a business where all decisions, including capital allocation (i.e. using my money), are made by egomaniac not knowing his limitations and throwing off shareholders' resources on his dreams. So many great institutions (and even countries) destroyed by egomaniacs. Investing is not all about coefficients and growth rates. Don't forget the art part.

Grahamites
Grahamites premium member - 1 month ago

Vargsmane - I appreciate your honest opinion. I've made my judgment based on the evidences, both confirming and disconfirming. It's my assessment that JD's moat has eroded significantly and I'd rather own Alibaba. I respect your own assessments.

Grahamites
Grahamites premium member - 1 month ago

Science - Thanks for the encouragements. I sincerely hope in the future there would be fewer articles like this one:)

Grahamites
Grahamites premium member - 1 month ago

Tim1248 - Thanks for commenting. Yes that was a troubling sign indeed. I don't think Liu look at competition rationally.

Grahamites
Grahamites premium member - 1 month ago

Viacheslav - Thanks for the nice words. I've been a pro in making mistakes:) There's always so much to learn.

Alberthahalfacre
Alberthahalfacre - 1 month ago    Report SPAM

A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing this data. I extremely like your post in particular. You have extremely shared a useful and intriguing post with individuals keep sharing thoughtfully take a gander at it heaviest metal card

Please leave your comment:


Performances of the stocks mentioned by Grahamites


User Generated Screeners


pbarker465 yr Dividend growth >2%
DANGORDON11-18 REV INC GROWTH
DANGORDON11-18 REV INC GROWTH
pbarker46>S&P 1 mo
michaelgustitus11/17 2
michaelgustitus11/17
kislevamnontrial1
DANGORDON11-17-18 REV EARNINGS GROWTH
filip2001sandp500
sathyagajjala15value
Get WordPress Plugins for easy affiliate links on Stock Tickers and Guru Names | Earn affiliate commissions by embedding GuruFocus Charts
GuruFocus Affiliate Program: Earn up to $400 per referral. ( Learn More)

GF Chat

{{numOfNotice}}
FEEDBACK