Focused on building reliable datasets, financial models, and research tools for value-minded investors. Committed to turning complex data into practical guidance for value-investing and long-term wealth.
Dr. Charlie Tian is the founder and CEO of GuruFocus.com, a leading global investment research platform established in 2004. With a Ph.D. in physics, Dr. Tian transitioned from science to finance, applying a data-driven, disciplined approach to value investing.
Carlyle CommoditiesFRA:BJ4 Piotroski F-Score is 3 as of Jul. 23, 2026, which is at its 10-year median of 3.00. The stock has 1 warning sign investors should review. Among 2,502 Metals & Mining companies, Carlyle Commodities ranks better than 59.19% on this metric.
Warning Sign:
Piotroski F-Score of 3 is low, which usually implies poor business operation.
The zones of discrimination were as such:
Good or high score = 7, 8, 9
Bad or low score = 0, 1, 2, 3
Carlyle Commodities has an F-score of 3. It is a bad or low score, which usually implies poor business operation.
The historical rank and industry rank for Carlyle Commodities's Piotroski F-Score or its related term are showing as below:
FRA:BJ4'
s Piotroski F-Score Range Over the Past 10 Years
Min: 3 Med: 3 Max: 4
Current: 3
During the past 9 years, the highest Piotroski F-Score of Carlyle Commodities was 4. The lowest was 3. And the median was 3.
The developer of the system is Joseph D. Piotroski is relatively unknown accounting professor who shuns publicity and rarely gives interviews.
He graduated from the University of Illinois with a B.S. in accounting in 1989, received an M.B.A. from Indiana University in 1994. Five years later, in 1999, after earning a Ph.D. in accounting from the University of Michigan, he became an associate professor of accounting at the University of Chicago.
He wanted to see if he can develop a system (using a simple nine-point scoring system) that can increase the returns of a strategy of investing in low price to book (referred to in the paper as high book to market) value companies.
What he found was something that exceeded his most optimistic expectations.
Buying only those companies that scored highest (8 or 9) on his nine-point scale, or F-Score as he called it, over the 20 year period from 1976 to 1996 led to an average out-performance over the market of 13.4%.
Even more impressive were the results of a strategy of investing in the highest F-Score companies (8 or 9) and shorting companies with the lowest F-Score (0 or 1).
Over the same period from 1976 to 1996 (20 years) this strategy led to an average yearly return of 23%, substantially outperforming the average S&P 500 index return of 15.83% over the same period.
Carlyle Commodities Piotroski F-Score Related Terms
Carlyle Commodities Piotroski F-Score Historical Data
* Premium members only.
The historical data trend for Carlyle Commodities's Piotroski F-Score can be seen below:
* For Operating Data section: All numbers are indicated by the unit behind each term and all currency related amount are in USD. * For other sections: All numbers are in millions except for per share data, ratio, and percentage. All currency related amount are indicated in the company's associated stock exchange currency.
FRA:BJ4 vs GKOR, MAGE, ALGLF: Piotroski F-Score Comparison
For the Gold subindustry, Carlyle Commodities's Piotroski F-Score, along with its competitors' market caps and Piotroski F-Score data, can be viewed below:
* Competitive companies are chosen from companies within the same industry, with headquarter located in same country, with closest market capitalization; x-axis shows the market cap, and y-axis shows the term value; the bigger the dot, the larger the market cap. Note that "N/A" values will not show up in the chart.
Carlyle Commodities Piotroski F-Score vs Metals & Mining Industry
For the Metals & Mining industry and Basic Materials sector, Carlyle Commodities's Piotroski F-Score distribution charts can be found below:
* The bar in red indicates where Carlyle Commodities's Piotroski F-Score falls into.
* For Operating Data section: All numbers are indicated by the unit behind each term and all currency related amount are in USD. * For other sections: All numbers are in millions except for per share data, ratio, and percentage. All currency related amount are indicated in the company's associated stock exchange currency.
*Note: If the latest quarterly/semi-annual/annual total assets data is 0, then we will use previous quarterly/semi-annual/annual data for all the items in the balance sheet.
Profitability
Question 1. Return on Assets (ROA)
Net income before extraordinary items for the year divided by Total Assets at the beginning of the year.
Score 1 if positive, 0 if negative.
Carlyle Commodities's current Net Income (TTM) was -0.69.
==> Negative ==> Score 0.
Question 2. Cash Flow Return on Assets (CFROA)
Net cash flow from operating activities (operating cash flow) divided by Total Assets at the beginning of the year.
Carlyle Commodities's return on assets of this year was -0.3693454. Carlyle Commodities's return on assets of last year was -0.76.
==> This year is higher. ==> Score 1.
Question 4. Quality of Earnings (Accrual)
Compare Cash flow return on assets (2) to return on assets (1)
Carlyle Commodities's gearing of this year was 0. Carlyle Commodities's gearing of last year was 0.
==> This year is lower or equal to last year. ==> Score 1.
Question 6. Change in Working Capital (Liquidity)
Compare this year's current ratio (current assets divided by current liabilities) to last year's current ratio.
Score 1 if this year's current ratio is higher, 0 if it's lower
Carlyle Commodities's current ratio of this year was 1.28737598. Carlyle Commodities's current ratio of last year was 2.9790795.
==> Last year's current ratio is higher ==> Score 0.
Question 7. Change in Shares in Issue
Compare the number of shares in issue this year, to the number in issue last year.
Score 0 if there is larger number of shares in issue this year, 1 otherwise.
Carlyle Commodities's number of shares in issue this year was 5.357. Carlyle Commodities's number of shares in issue last year was 4.364.
==> There is larger number of shares in issue this year. ==> Score 0.
Efficiency
Question 8. Change in Gross Margin
Compare this year's gross margin (Gross Profit divided by sales) to last year's.
Score 1 if this year's gross margin is higher, 0 if it's lower.
Carlyle Commodities's gross margin of this year was . Carlyle Commodities's gross margin of last year was .
==> Last year's gross margin is higher ==> Score 0.
Question 9. Change in asset turnover
Compare this year's asset turnover (total sales for the year divided by total assets at the beginning of the year) to last year's asset turnover ratio.
Score 1 if this year's asset turnover ratio is higher, 0 if it's lower
Carlyle Commodities's asset turnover of this year was 0. Carlyle Commodities's asset turnover of last year was 0.
==> Last year's asset turnover is higher ==> Score 0.
Evaluation
Piotroski F-Score
=
Que. 1
+
Que. 2
+
Que. 3
+
Que. 4
+
Que. 5
+
Que. 6
+
Que. 7
+
Que. 8
+
Que. 9
=
0
+
0
+
1
+
1
+
1
+
0
+
0
+
0
+
0
=
3
Good or high score = 7, 8, 9
Bad or low score = 0, 1, 2, 3
Carlyle Commodities has an F-score of 3. It is a bad or low score, which usually implies poor business operation.
Carlyle Commodities (FRA:BJ4) has a Piotroski F-Score of 3 as of Jul. 23, 2026. The Piotroski F-score grades a company's business operating strength from 0-9. View historical data on Carlyle Commodities and its competitors. This is near median its historical median of 3.00. Over the past decade, Carlyle Commodities' Piotroski F-Score has ranged from 3.00 to 4.00. According to the industry distribution chart, Carlyle Commodities ranks #1021 out of 2502 companies in the Metals & Mining industry, placing it in the top 40.8%.
Is Carlyle Commodities' Piotroski F-Score too high?
Carlyle Commodities' current Piotroski F-Score of 3 is near median its 10-year median of 3.00. Over the past 10 years, this metric has ranged from a low of 3.00 to a high of 4.00. The Metals & Mining industry median Piotroski F-Score is 3.00. Carlyle Commodities' value of 3 is 0% at this industry median. Based on the distribution chart, Carlyle Commodities ranks #1021 out of 2502 companies in the Metals & Mining industry, which is above the industry midpoint.
How does Carlyle Commodities' Piotroski F-Score compare to GKOR and MAGE?
According to the Metals & Mining industry distribution chart, Carlyle Commodities ranks #1021 out of 2502 companies for Piotroski F-Score. This puts Carlyle Commodities in the upper half of its industry. The industry median Piotroski F-Score is 3.00. Carlyle Commodities' value of 3 is 0% at this benchmark. Historically, Carlyle Commodities' own Piotroski F-Score has ranged from 3.00 to 4.00 over the past decade. While the company's 10-year median is 3.00 vs. the industry median of 3.00, Carlyle Commodities has consistently been at the industry average. See the competitive comparison table and distribution chart on this page for a detailed peer-by-peer breakdown.
What is a good Piotroski F-Score for a Metals & Mining company?
The median Piotroski F-Score among Metals & Mining companies is 3.00, based on 2,502 companies in the industry. Companies in the top quartile (top 25%) have a Piotroski F-Score significantly above this median, while those in the bottom quartile fall well below. However, Piotroski F-Score should not be evaluated in isolation — investors should consider it alongside profitability, growth, and financial strength metrics. Carlyle Commodities's current Piotroski F-Score of 3 is 0% at the industry median. Use the industry distribution chart on this page to see where any company falls relative to its peers.
What does a high Piotroski F-Score mean?
A high Piotroski F-Score can signal that a stock is expensive relative to its fundamentals. The Piotroski F-score grades a company's business operating strength from 0-9. View historical data on Carlyle Commodities and its competitors. For the Metals & Mining industry, the median Piotroski F-Score is 3.00 — values significantly above this may indicate overvaluation, while values below may suggest a bargain or underlying issues. Carlyle Commodities's current Piotroski F-Score is 3, which is near median its own 10-year median of 3.00. However, context matters — high-growth companies often justify higher valuations. Always evaluate alongside other metrics like GF Score™ and GF Value™.
Is Carlyle Commodities stock overvalued right now?
Carlyle Commodities (FRA:BJ4) has a current Piotroski F-Score of 3. The current Piotroski F-Score is 3, which is near median its 10-year median of 3.00 and 0% at the Metals & Mining industry median of 3.00. Investors should evaluate multiple metrics — including profitability, growth, and financial strength — before making a decision.
How is Piotroski F-Score calculated?
Piotroski F-Score is calculated from a company's financial statements. For Carlyle Commodities (FRA:BJ4), the current Piotroski F-Score is 3 as of Jul. 23, 2026. GuruFocus calculates this using data sourced from SEC filings and annual reports. See the calculation section and 30-year financial data on this page for the full breakdown.
Carlyle Commodities Corp focuses on the acquisition, exploration, and development of mineral resource properties in Canada. Its project portfolio comprises the Quesnel Gold Project and the Nicola East Property located in British Columbia, Canada.
Quick Browse
Personalize
Premium Gurus 
Create New Portfolio
FRA:BJ4 has been successfully added to your 
